RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter vs Smart Product Filter & Searchfor Shopify (2026)
Both RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter and Smart Product Filter & Search aim to improve product discovery on Shopify stores using AI-powered search and filtering. RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter emphasizes theme compatibility, speed (scaling to 1M+ products), and an always-visible search bar, positioning itself for merchants who prioritize seamless integration and high performance. Smart Product Filter & Search, on the other hand, highlights its comprehensive filtering options (unlimited filter menus, metafield and variant filtering) and advanced AI search features like Year Make Model search and search redirects, making it attractive to stores with complex product catalogs and a need for granular control over search results. The higher review count for Smart Product Filter & Search suggests wider adoption and potentially more user-reported experience data.
At a Glance
RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter
310 reviews
Smart Product Filter & Search
1,818 reviews
Detailed Overview
RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter
Replace the search icon with an AI Search Bar, add Product & Collection Filters to improve discovery
Key Features
- AI Search Bar: show typo-tolerant, predictive instant search results instantly
- Always-Visible Search Bar: Replace the search icon to boost engagement & sales
- Custom product filters & collection filters: tag filter, metafield, variant, etc
- Product merchandising: pin, boost, demote, or hide to spotlight bestsellers
- Scales to 1M+ products: blazing fast, no slowdown, works with any theme
Smart Product Filter & Search
Help shoppers find what they mean with AI-powered search, smart filters, and instant results
Key Features
- Smart filter app to custom filter for different collection filter, category.
- Unlimited filter menu by tag, sale %, review, metafields, variants filter...
- AI-powered search and discovery solution. Year Make Model search
- AI semantic search, Full-text search, Auto-suggestion, Search Redirects etc.
- 9 Product recommendation types. Analytics with filter & search behavior report.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.8/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter4.8/5 Smart Product Filter & Search4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 310 | 1818 |
Reviews RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter310 Smart Product Filter & Search1818 | ||
| AI Search Capabilities | Typo-tolerant, predictive, semantic understanding | Semantic search, Full-text search, Auto-suggestion, Search Redirects |
AI Search Capabilities RS: Smart Search Bar & FilterTypo-tolerant, predictive, semantic understanding Smart Product Filter & SearchSemantic search, Full-text search, Auto-suggestion, Search Redirects | ||
| Filtering Options | Custom filters: tag, metafield, variant, etc. | Unlimited filter menu by tag, sale %, review, metafields, variants |
Filtering Options RS: Smart Search Bar & FilterCustom filters: tag, metafield, variant, etc. Smart Product Filter & SearchUnlimited filter menu by tag, sale %, review, metafields, variants | ||
| Unique Features | Always-Visible Search Bar | 9 Product recommendation types, Analytics with filter & search behavior report, Display product variants as separate products |
Unique Features RS: Smart Search Bar & FilterAlways-Visible Search Bar Smart Product Filter & Search9 Product recommendation types, Analytics with filter & search behavior report, Display product variants as separate products | ||
| Scalability | Scales to 1M+ products | Not explicitly stated |
Scalability RS: Smart Search Bar & FilterScales to 1M+ products Smart Product Filter & SearchNot explicitly stated | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants prioritizing theme compatibility and speed | Merchants with complex catalogs needing granular search control |
Target Merchant RS: Smart Search Bar & FilterMerchants prioritizing theme compatibility and speed Smart Product Filter & SearchMerchants with complex catalogs needing granular search control | ||
| Value Proposition | Faster search, cleaner navigation, higher conversions | Help shoppers find what they mean with AI-powered search |
Value Proposition RS: Smart Search Bar & FilterFaster search, cleaner navigation, higher conversions Smart Product Filter & SearchHelp shoppers find what they mean with AI-powered search | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily concerned with integrating seamlessly with their existing theme and ensuring rapid search performance, especially at scale, RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter is a strong choice. Its focus on speed and ease of integration makes it suitable for stores that want a quick and effective upgrade to their search functionality. However, for stores with more complex product catalogs, a greater need for precise control over search results, and a desire to leverage product recommendations and analytics, Smart Product Filter & Search offers a more comprehensive feature set, justifying the slightly lower rating but significantly higher review count, signaling greater experience with its capabilities. Merchants should weigh the importance of integration simplicity against feature depth when making their decision.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter likely prioritizes ease of setup given its emphasis on theme compatibility and not breaking page speed. Smart Product Filter & Search, with its more extensive feature set, may require a steeper learning curve to configure effectively.
Does one app offer better merchandising options?
RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter explicitly mentions product merchandising features like pinning, boosting, demoting, or hiding products. While Smart Product Filter & Search has product recommendations, it doesn't detail similar merchandising controls.
Which app is better for stores with a high volume of products?
RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter specifically claims to scale to 1M+ products without slowdown, making it the better choice for very large catalogs. While Smart Product Filter & Search doesn't state a specific scaling capacity, the lack of emphasis on speed could suggest limitations compared to RS.
Do both apps offer typo tolerance in search?
RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter explicitly mentions typo tolerance. Smart Product Filter & Search details 'AI semantic search' which implies typo handling, but isn't as clearly stated.
Which app offers reporting and analytics?
Smart Product Filter & Search provides 'Analytics with filter & search behavior report', while RS: Smart Search Bar & Filter does not explicitly list this feature.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store