Seal Subscriptions App vs Subi: Subscriptions & Loyaltyfor Shopify (2026)
Both Seal Subscriptions App and Subi: Subscriptions & Loyalty are highly-rated Shopify apps (4.9/5) aiming to help merchants build recurring revenue through subscriptions and loyalty programs. Seal Subscriptions App emphasizes ease of setup and robust subscription management features, with a focus on full control over subscribers, products, and cancellations, appealing to merchants seeking a straightforward and powerful subscription solution. Subi, on the other hand, positions itself as an all-in-one solution, incorporating subscriptions, loyalty programs, and memberships, aiming to transform buyers into loyal subscribers with flexible billing and rewards, which caters to merchants seeking to build a holistic recurring revenue model. The key difference lies in their feature focus. Seal prioritizes subscription box functionality, advanced subscription discounts, and customer access via magic links, along with white-label branding, suggesting a focus on established subscription businesses looking to scale and customize their experience. Subi leans into loyalty program integration, tiered memberships, and flexible subscription boxes, making it a better fit for businesses wanting to build comprehensive loyalty programs and experiment with various recurring revenue models beyond simple product subscriptions. Subi also highlights its quick setup and direct integration into the Shopify admin, potentially appealing to less technically savvy users.
At a Glance
Seal Subscriptions App
1,994 reviews
Subi: Subscriptions & Loyalty
691 reviews
Detailed Overview
Seal Subscriptions App
Grow predictable revenue with product subscriptions and subscription boxes!
Key Features
- Sell classic & prepaid subscriptions, subscription boxes with discounts & more!
- Offer tiered discounts, custom shipping, free gifts and loyalty incentives
- Your customers can easily access subscriptions (abonnements) with magic links!
- Track revenue, gain insights and optimize performance with real-time analytics
- Use the white-label branding with custom email domains!
Subi: Subscriptions & Loyalty
Subscriptions & loyalty app for recurring payments, memberships, boxes and abonnements, without code
Key Features
- Quick setup and Auto-adding widget. Embed app to use directly in Shopify admin.
- Seamless subscriber portal to manage their subscriptions. Skip, pause & cancel.
- Flexible membership tiers offering multiple perks and member-only benefits
- Flexible subscription and mystery boxes that elevate AOV and customer experience
- Loyalty programs with points and rewards that drive repeat customer visits
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating Seal Subscriptions App4.9/5 Subi: Subscriptions & Loyalty4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1994 | 691 |
Reviews Seal Subscriptions App1994 Subi: Subscriptions & Loyalty691 | ||
| Core Focus | Subscription Management & Boxes | Subscriptions, Loyalty & Memberships |
Core Focus Seal Subscriptions AppSubscription Management & Boxes Subi: Subscriptions & LoyaltySubscriptions, Loyalty & Memberships | ||
| Key Features | Subscription boxes, tiered discounts, magic links, white-label branding | Loyalty programs, tiered memberships, flexible boxes, smart dunning |
Key Features Seal Subscriptions AppSubscription boxes, tiered discounts, magic links, white-label branding Subi: Subscriptions & LoyaltyLoyalty programs, tiered memberships, flexible boxes, smart dunning | ||
| Ease of Use Claim | Set up in minutes | Quick setup and auto-adding widget |
Ease of Use Claim Seal Subscriptions AppSet up in minutes Subi: Subscriptions & LoyaltyQuick setup and auto-adding widget | ||
| Customer Management | Full control over subscribers | Seamless subscriber portal (self-service) |
Customer Management Seal Subscriptions AppFull control over subscribers Subi: Subscriptions & LoyaltySeamless subscriber portal (self-service) | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses focused on scaling subscriptions and customization | Businesses building all-in-one loyalty & subscription programs |
Target Merchant Seal Subscriptions AppBusinesses focused on scaling subscriptions and customization Subi: Subscriptions & LoyaltyBusinesses building all-in-one loyalty & subscription programs | ||
| Support Origin | Made in Europe | Not specified |
Support Origin Seal Subscriptions AppMade in Europe Subi: Subscriptions & LoyaltyNot specified | ||
| AOV Emphasis | Subscription Boxes | Mystery Boxes to elevate AOV |
AOV Emphasis Seal Subscriptions AppSubscription Boxes Subi: Subscriptions & LoyaltyMystery Boxes to elevate AOV | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily focused on streamlining and scaling their existing subscription business, especially those offering subscription boxes and requiring white-label branding options, Seal Subscriptions App is the better choice due to its emphasis on subscription management and customizable branding. Its higher number of reviews further suggests a more mature and widely adopted platform.
However, if a merchant is looking to build a comprehensive loyalty program alongside subscriptions and offer tiered memberships with flexible rewards, Subi: Subscriptions & Loyalty offers a more complete solution. The ease of setup and direct integration into the Shopify admin also makes it a user-friendly choice for those with less technical expertise or who want to manage everything from a single interface.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
While both apps claim ease of setup, Subi highlights 'quick setup' and an 'auto-adding widget,' suggesting a potentially smoother onboarding process, particularly for less technical users.
Which app is better for subscription boxes?
Both apps support subscription boxes. However, Seal Subscriptions App prominently features subscription boxes in its headline and key features, indicating a deeper focus on and potentially more robust support for this specific type of subscription model.
Which app is better for loyalty programs?
Subi: Subscriptions & Loyalty is the clear choice for loyalty programs. It explicitly incorporates loyalty programs with points and rewards, as well as tiered memberships, which are not primary features of Seal Subscriptions App.
Does either app offer advanced analytics?
Both apps mention analytics. Seal Subscriptions App refers to 'real-time analytics' for tracking revenue and optimizing performance, while Subi refers to analytics to grow and retain subscribers. This implies both offer some form of data reporting, but the specific depth and granularity of the analytics remain unclear without further investigation.
Which app provides more customization options?
Seal Subscriptions App highlights 'white-label branding' with custom email domains, offering greater control over the visual identity and brand experience. Subi mentions widget customization but does not emphasize the breadth of customization options to the same extent.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store