Shipping Rates by Postcode vs Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)for Shopify (2026)
Shipping Rates by Postcode and Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) are both Shopify apps in the Delivery and pickup category, but cater to different needs. Shipping Rates by Postcode focuses on providing accurate, carrier-calculated shipping rates based on location, weight, and cart contents. Its primary aim is to reduce cart abandonment by offering transparent shipping costs and enabling merchants to manage shipping profitability by configuring advanced rules based on postcode or region. It seems globally available with good support for AUS, UK, NZ, CA and more, requiring carrier calculated shipping to use. Store Pickup + Delivery (CR), on the other hand, is geared towards merchants offering local pickup and/or delivery options. Its strength lies in scheduling and managing these local fulfillment methods, allowing customers to choose pickup/delivery dates and times, and enabling merchants to control capacity and organization through time slot limits and order tagging. Its feature set is particularly suitable for businesses like restaurants managing local order fulfillment, or any retailer wanting to enable easy local order pickup.
At a Glance
Shipping Rates by Postcode
112 reviews
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)
350 reviews
Detailed Overview
Shipping Rates by Postcode
Boost Sales & Avoid Lost Revenue from Surprise Shipping Costs with Carrier Calculated Shipping Rates
Key Features
- Shipping Rates in the Cart: For countries, regions, neighborhoods, & post codes
- Calculate Shipping Rates: Based on location, postal code, weight, cart contents
- Shipping Rate Tiers: Extensive shipping support on a local & global basis
- Product Groups: Offer unique shipping rates based on specific products
- Advanced Shipping Rules: Easily test delivery rates across your zones
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)
Boost sales with flexible delivery and local order pickup scheduling that improves local fulfillment
Key Features
- Set minimum pickup days, preparation time, blackout specific days
- Easily organize local pickup or local delivery orders with the help of tags
- Limit number of local pickup orders per time slot or per day
- Offer delivery each day in specific zip code areas. Offer location surcharge.
- Disable shipping by making a specific collection mandatory for pickup.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Shipping Rates by Postcode4.9/5 Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 112 | 350 |
Reviews Shipping Rates by Postcode112 Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)350 | ||
| Core Functionality | Carrier-calculated shipping rates by postcode/region | Local pickup and delivery scheduling & management |
Core Functionality Shipping Rates by PostcodeCarrier-calculated shipping rates by postcode/region Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Local pickup and delivery scheduling & management | ||
| Target Merchant | E-commerce businesses needing precise global or local shipping rates | Businesses offering local pickup/delivery, especially restaurants |
Target Merchant Shipping Rates by PostcodeE-commerce businesses needing precise global or local shipping rates Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Businesses offering local pickup/delivery, especially restaurants | ||
| Pricing Structure | Likely tier based on order volume and other criteria (not explicitly stated) | Likely tier based on order volume and other criteria (not explicitly stated) |
Pricing Structure Shipping Rates by PostcodeLikely tier based on order volume and other criteria (not explicitly stated) Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Likely tier based on order volume and other criteria (not explicitly stated) | ||
| Ease of Use | Potentially moderate complexity due to advanced rule configuration | Likely moderate complexity due to scheduling and location settings |
Ease of Use Shipping Rates by PostcodePotentially moderate complexity due to advanced rule configuration Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Likely moderate complexity due to scheduling and location settings | ||
| Value Proposition | Reduce cart abandonment, increase shipping profitability | Improve customer experience with flexible pickup/delivery, streamline local fulfillment |
Value Proposition Shipping Rates by PostcodeReduce cart abandonment, increase shipping profitability Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Improve customer experience with flexible pickup/delivery, streamline local fulfillment | ||
| Carrier Calculated Shipping Requirement | Yes | No |
Carrier Calculated Shipping Requirement Shipping Rates by PostcodeYes Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)No | ||
Our Verdict
If your priority is accurate shipping rates for your online store, especially if you ship internationally and need to control shipping costs based on location and weight, then Shipping Rates by Postcode is the better choice. Its advanced shipping rules and ability to calculate rates based on various factors offer fine-grained control. However, if you are a local business, particularly a restaurant, seeking to improve your local order fulfillment by giving your customers choices in how and when they receive their orders, then Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) is the stronger option. Its scheduling and location management features are well-suited for this purpose.
Common Questions
Which app is better for reducing cart abandonment due to shipping costs?
Shipping Rates by Postcode is specifically designed to address this issue by providing real-time, accurate shipping rates.
Can Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) handle shipping rates?
While Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) focuses on local fulfillment, it can disable standard shipping by requiring a collection is mandatory for pickup, but it doesn't directly offer carrier-calculated shipping rates.
Which app is suitable for a restaurant offering takeout and delivery?
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) is designed specifically for this purpose, offering features for scheduling pickups and deliveries and controlling time slots.
Does Shipping Rates by Postcode support international shipping?
Yes, Shipping Rates by Postcode offers global shipping rate calculation support, including for AUS, UK, NZ, and CA.
Which app is easier to set up and manage?
Both apps likely have a learning curve. Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) might be simpler if you only need local fulfillment. Shipping Rates by Postcode's advanced rules may require more configuration time.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store