ShipPro Shipping Protection vs Simply Shipping Protectionfor Shopify (2026)
Both ShipPro Shipping Protection and Simply Shipping Protection offer Shopify merchants the ability to sell shipping protection to their customers and retain 100% of the profit, positioning themselves as alternatives to third-party insurance providers like Route, Captain Insur, and Navidium. The core value proposition centers around revenue generation and enhanced customer trust by offering order protection. However, they differ in their approach to claims management and the level of customization offered. ShipPro focuses on ease of use and seamless integration with themes, while Simply Shipping Protection emphasizes control over the entire claims process and detailed analytics. Simply Shipping Protection seems geared toward merchants who want granular control over the entire customer experience, from pricing and display to claims resolution. They provide tools for merchants to manage claims directly within the app using refunds, reorders, or store credit. ShipPro Shipping Protection targets merchants who value simplicity and a streamlined process, preferring a pre-built, intuitive design and seamless theme integration. Its focus is on revenue-increasing features, implying less emphasis on manual claims management. The choice between the two depends heavily on a merchant's desire to be hands-on with claims versus prioritizing a hands-off, revenue-focused solution.
At a Glance
ShipPro Shipping Protection
37 reviews
Simply Shipping Protection
127 reviews
Detailed Overview
ShipPro Shipping Protection
Sell Shipping Protection + Increase Revenue and Trust = Keep 100% profit
Key Features
- Revenue Increasing Features (Pre-tick, Scaling Insurance, One Tick Upsell)
- ShipProtect Integration Seamlessly With All Major Themes
- Simple Intuitive Design & Product Setup Tools With Experienced Support Team
Simply Shipping Protection
Let customers protect their orders while you keep the full fee and manage claims your way.
Key Features
- Set fixed or percentage (%) pricing and show toggle with opt-in popup
- Customize and show widgets on cart, side cart, checkout, or post-purchase
- Let customers file claims with a widget placed on any store page
- Settle claims with refunds, reorders, or credits using built-in integrations
- Track revenue and claims in one clean dashboard
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.5/5 | 4.7/5 |
Rating ShipPro Shipping Protection4.5/5 Simply Shipping Protection4.7/5 | ||
| Reviews | 37 | 127 |
Reviews ShipPro Shipping Protection37 Simply Shipping Protection127 | ||
| Claims Management | Implicitly uses merchant's own processes | Integrated claims management (refunds, reorders, credits) |
Claims Management ShipPro Shipping ProtectionImplicitly uses merchant's own processes Simply Shipping ProtectionIntegrated claims management (refunds, reorders, credits) | ||
| Customization | Seamless theme integration | Highly customizable widgets (cart, checkout, post-purchase) |
Customization ShipPro Shipping ProtectionSeamless theme integration Simply Shipping ProtectionHighly customizable widgets (cart, checkout, post-purchase) | ||
| Key Focus | Revenue generation, Ease of Use | Control over claims, Detailed Analytics |
Key Focus ShipPro Shipping ProtectionRevenue generation, Ease of Use Simply Shipping ProtectionControl over claims, Detailed Analytics | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants prioritizing simplicity and a hands-off approach | Merchants desiring full control over claims and customer experience |
Target Merchant ShipPro Shipping ProtectionMerchants prioritizing simplicity and a hands-off approach Simply Shipping ProtectionMerchants desiring full control over claims and customer experience | ||
| Analytics | Not explicitly mentioned | Real-time analytics dashboard |
Analytics ShipPro Shipping ProtectionNot explicitly mentioned Simply Shipping ProtectionReal-time analytics dashboard | ||
| Pricing Options | Scaling Insurance | Fixed or percentage pricing |
Pricing Options ShipPro Shipping ProtectionScaling Insurance Simply Shipping ProtectionFixed or percentage pricing | ||
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants seeking a streamlined, hands-off approach to shipping protection with a focus on maximizing revenue, ShipPro Shipping Protection is likely the better choice. Its emphasis on easy integration and revenue-increasing features aligns with businesses that prefer simplicity and less direct involvement in claims handling. It's suited for businesses with established customer service protocols that they want to maintain.
Conversely, Simply Shipping Protection is more appropriate for merchants who want complete control over the shipping protection experience and are willing to actively manage claims. The app's comprehensive claims management tools, customization options, and real-time analytics provide the flexibility and insights needed for businesses that prioritize a tailored customer experience. This is ideal for larger merchants with established support teams, or for merchants that need custom returns/replacement options.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up and use?
ShipPro Shipping Protection explicitly highlights its "Simple Intuitive Design & Product Setup Tools," suggesting a smoother and faster onboarding experience compared to Simply Shipping Protection, which might require more configuration due to its extensive customization options.
Which app provides better analytics?
Simply Shipping Protection offers a "real-time analytics dashboard," providing merchants with detailed insights into revenue and claims. ShipPro Shipping Protection does not explicitly mention dedicated analytics capabilities.
Which app gives me more control over the look and feel of the shipping protection offer?
Simply Shipping Protection allows merchants to customize widgets on various store pages (cart, side cart, checkout, post-purchase). This means a merchant can precisely control where and how the shipping protection offer appears. ShipPro prioritizes seamless theme integration but offers less granular widget control.
If a customer files a claim, how do the apps handle it differently?
Simply Shipping Protection provides built-in integrations to settle claims directly within the app by issuing refunds, reorders, or store credits. ShipPro Shipping Protection does not mention a direct claim resolution process, implying the merchant is responsible for handling claims through their existing customer service channels.
Which app is better for increasing order value?
Both apps aim to increase order value through shipping protection premiums. ShipPro explicitly mentions features like "Pre-tick, Scaling Insurance, One Tick Upsell," which are designed to actively encourage customers to add protection, potentially leading to a higher order value. Simply Shipping Protection focuses on customization, which indirectly can increase order value, but does not explicitly claim upselling features.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store