Simply Shipping Protection vs xCotton Post Purchase Guardfor Shopify (2026)
Simply Shipping Protection and xCotton Post Purchase Guard both address the need for returns and warranty solutions on Shopify, but they cater to different merchant needs and operational preferences. Simply Shipping Protection is positioned as a fully customizable, in-house shipping protection solution where merchants retain full control over pricing, placement, and claims management. This app appeals to merchants seeking autonomy and those wanting to integrate the protection seamlessly with their existing loyalty and support systems. xCotton Post Purchase Guard, while lacking specific feature details, boasts a higher rating and more reviews, suggesting strong customer satisfaction, which, in 2026, is a key consideration for merchants prioritizing a smooth user experience and established reliability. The provided information limits a granular comparison; we'll need more data to determine if xCotton is also a first-party solution. The key differentiator appears to be the control offered by Simply Shipping Protection. Merchants who want to directly manage claims, customize the offering's placement within their store (cart, checkout, post-purchase), and integrate with their existing tech stack will find Simply Shipping Protection a more suitable choice. Conversely, xCotton's higher rating and review count signal a potentially more streamlined, easier-to-use solution, even though the specific features remain obscured. We expect more transparency from the app descriptions, which could lead merchants to lean into the app with more readily-available details. However, the higher reviews suggest strong value to its current users.
At a Glance
Simply Shipping Protection
127 reviews
xCotton Post Purchase Guard
152 reviews
Detailed Overview
Simply Shipping Protection
Let customers protect their orders while you keep the full fee and manage claims your way.
Key Features
- Set fixed or percentage (%) pricing and show toggle with opt-in popup
- Customize and show widgets on cart, side cart, checkout, or post-purchase
- Let customers file claims with a widget placed on any store page
- Settle claims with refunds, reorders, or credits using built-in integrations
- Track revenue and claims in one clean dashboard
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.7/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Simply Shipping Protection4.7/5 xCotton Post Purchase Guard5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 127 | 152 |
Reviews Simply Shipping Protection127 xCotton Post Purchase Guard152 | ||
| Control Over Claims | Full control; direct claims management | Undetermined (likely less control based on description gap) |
Control Over Claims Simply Shipping ProtectionFull control; direct claims management xCotton Post Purchase GuardUndetermined (likely less control based on description gap) | ||
| Customization | High: Pricing, Placement (Cart, Checkout, Post-Purchase) | Undetermined (based on data) |
Customization Simply Shipping ProtectionHigh: Pricing, Placement (Cart, Checkout, Post-Purchase) xCotton Post Purchase GuardUndetermined (based on data) | ||
| Integrations | Built-in integrations for refunds, reorders, store credits, loyalty, support | Unknown |
Integrations Simply Shipping ProtectionBuilt-in integrations for refunds, reorders, store credits, loyalty, support xCotton Post Purchase GuardUnknown | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants seeking autonomy and advanced customization options | Merchants prioritizing high ratings and possibly simpler setup |
Target Merchant Simply Shipping ProtectionMerchants seeking autonomy and advanced customization options xCotton Post Purchase GuardMerchants prioritizing high ratings and possibly simpler setup | ||
| Value Proposition | Full control over shipping protection revenue and claims process | Strong Customer Satisfaction. Simplified setup/management (assumption based on limited data) |
Value Proposition Simply Shipping ProtectionFull control over shipping protection revenue and claims process xCotton Post Purchase GuardStrong Customer Satisfaction. Simplified setup/management (assumption based on limited data) | ||
| Pricing Flexibility | Set fixed or percentage pricing | Undetermined (based on data) |
Pricing Flexibility Simply Shipping ProtectionSet fixed or percentage pricing xCotton Post Purchase GuardUndetermined (based on data) | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing complete control over their shipping protection program, including pricing, placement, and claims management, Simply Shipping Protection is the clear choice. Its flexible customization options and direct integrations empower merchants to tailor the protection to their specific needs and brand. This is especially useful for stores with sophisticated loyalty programs or those who prefer to handle customer support directly.
However, for merchants primarily concerned with ease of use and a proven track record of customer satisfaction, xCotton Post Purchase Guard, with its higher rating and greater number of reviews, might be a more suitable starting point. While its specific features are not fully detailed, the high ratings suggest a potentially more streamlined and reliable solution. Further research into xCotton's features and support documentation is warranted before making a final decision. Ultimately, the best choice depends on the merchant's individual priorities and operational style.
Common Questions
Which app offers more control over the claims process?
Simply Shipping Protection offers full control over the claims process, allowing merchants to manage and settle claims directly within the app.
Which app has better customer reviews?
xCotton Post Purchase Guard has a slightly higher rating (5/5 vs. 4.7/5) and more reviews (152 vs. 127) than Simply Shipping Protection.
Which app is easier to set up?
Based on limited data, xCotton may be easier to set up, as it is likely that a 5/5 app will be easy to install and use out-of-box. Simply Shipping Protection requires more configuration to leverage fully; therefore it is likely harder to use initially but is worth it if you need the extra customization.
Which app allows me to customize where the shipping protection offer is displayed?
Simply Shipping Protection allows you to show widgets on the cart, side cart, checkout, or post-purchase pages. Details for xCotton are unknown.
Which app would be best for a small business just starting out?
Given the available data, xCotton Post Purchase Guard may be a better fit for a small business just starting out. The high rating and higher review count suggest a more straightforward and reliable solution. Small businesses often prioritize simplicity and ease of use, which xCotton appears to offer. However, further investigation is needed to determine xCotton's feature set fully.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store