In 2026, merchants choosing a Shopify wishlist app face a distinct contrast between Wishlist by Square and Wishlist ProX. Wishlist by Square positions itself as an easy-to-use, comprehensive wishlist solution focused on driving sales through saved favorites. It emphasizes out-of-the-box functionality, eliminating the need for customer accounts initially and providing valuable analytics on customer preferences and wishlist value. Wishlist ProX, on the other hand, lacks any user reviews or ratings at this point, making its positioning and strengths unclear based on the available data. The primary distinction lies in the user feedback and apparent functionality; Square boasts a perfect 5/5 rating and 11 reviews, whereas ProX has neither. Wishlist by Square appears to be targeted at Shopify merchants of all sizes who seek a straightforward, well-integrated wishlist solution that provides actionable insights. Its language support and customizable design cater to diverse store aesthetics and international audiences. The absence of reviews and information for Wishlist ProX makes it difficult to ascertain its target audience or intended benefits. Currently, Wishlist by Square's strength lies in its established presence, positive user feedback, and feature set designed for ease of use and data-driven decision-making. Merchants prioritizing a tested and reviewed solution will lean towards Square.
11 reviews
0 reviews
Boost sales with Wishlist features - let shoppers save favorites in a personal wish list
| Rating | 5/5 | 0/5 |
Rating Wishlist by Square5/5 Wishlist ProX0/5 | ||
| Reviews | 11 | 0 |
Reviews Wishlist by Square11 Wishlist ProX0 | ||
| Account Required | No (initially) | Unknown |
Account Required Wishlist by SquareNo (initially) Wishlist ProXUnknown | ||
| Customization | Yes (text, colors, icons, placement) | Unknown |
Customization Wishlist by SquareYes (text, colors, icons, placement) Wishlist ProXUnknown | ||
| Analytics | Yes (saved products, wishlist value, shopper interest) | Unknown |
Analytics Wishlist by SquareYes (saved products, wishlist value, shopper interest) Wishlist ProXUnknown | ||
| Language Support | 15 languages | Unknown |
Language Support Wishlist by Square15 languages Wishlist ProXUnknown | ||
| Ease of Use | Out-of-the-box functionality | Unknown |
Ease of Use Wishlist by SquareOut-of-the-box functionality Wishlist ProXUnknown | ||
| Value Proposition | Boost sales with wishlist features and insights | Unknown |
Value Proposition Wishlist by SquareBoost sales with wishlist features and insights Wishlist ProXUnknown | ||
For Shopify merchants in 2026, Wishlist by Square appears to be the more reliable and feature-rich choice based on current data. Its proven track record, positive user reviews, and comprehensive feature set make it a compelling option for merchants seeking to enhance customer engagement and drive sales through wishlists. It particularly suits businesses that want immediate value and don't have the resources for extensive customization or troubleshooting.
Wishlist ProX remains an unknown entity. Without any reviews or detailed feature information, it's difficult to recommend it over Wishlist by Square at this time. Risk-tolerant merchants willing to potentially encounter bugs or undocumented limitations might consider exploring ProX if later updates reveal unique value, but should proceed with caution. For most, Wishlist by Square is the safer and more practical option.
Wishlist by Square does *not* initially require customer accounts, saving and tracking products automatically. Whether Wishlist ProX requires an account is unknown based on available information.
Wishlist by Square tracks saved products, wishlist value, and shopper interest, providing valuable insights for merchants. No information is available regarding analytics provided by Wishlist ProX.
Wishlist by Square allows customization of text, colors, icons, and placement. Customization options for Wishlist ProX are unknown.
Wishlist by Square is described as working 'out of the box,' suggesting a simpler setup process. Ease of use for Wishlist ProX is currently unknown.
Wishlist by Square has 11 reviews and a rating of 5/5. Wishlist ProX has no reviews at this time.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store