While FraudGuard offers fraud prevention with order holds, customer verification, and custom rules, merchants may seek alternatives due to pricing concerns, feature gaps in specific areas of fraud protection, or a desire for simpler interfaces. Some merchants might find its approach too broad, needing solutions targeted at specific fraud types. As a store grows, the need for more sophisticated analysis and a wider range of preventative measures can also drive the search for a more robust system.
This guide explores several compelling alternatives to FraudGuard, each offering unique strengths in fraud prevention. We'll highlight key differences to help you choose the best solution for your Shopify store, from specialized tools focusing on delivery scams to comprehensive platforms leveraging AI and human review.
While FraudGuard offers fraud prevention with order holds, customer verification, and custom rules, merchants may seek alternatives due to pricing concerns, feature gaps in specific areas of fraud protection, or a desire for simpler interfaces. Some merchants might find its approach too broad, needing solutions targeted at specific fraud types. As a store grows, the need for more sophisticated analysis and a wider range of preventative measures can also drive the search for a more robust system.
This guide explores several compelling alternatives to FraudGuard, each offering unique strengths in fraud prevention. We'll highlight key differences to help you choose the best solution for your Shopify store, from specialized tools focusing on delivery scams to comprehensive platforms leveraging AI and human review.
Automate Chargebacks and Prevent Fraudulent Disputes with AI + Human Oversight
Why Consider
Chargeback Specialist provides a more hands-on approach to chargeback management than FraudGuard by offering AI-powered dispute responses tailored to your store and human review. This alternative helps recover revenue lost to unfair chargebacks and fraudulent disputes, aiming to improve win rates by providing strong and compelling responses based on chargeback guidelines.
Best For
Ideal for stores that want to automate chargeback responses and recover lost revenue due to disputes.
Build fraud filter rules that auto-block orders. Prevent chargebacks and protect revenue in 2min.
Why Consider
Fraud Falcon provides a more granular level of control over fraud prevention compared to FraudGuard by allowing merchants to create their own custom fraud filter rules. You can choose the action taken when a rule is triggered, like automatically canceling and refunding orders, offering greater flexibility in how you handle risky transactions.
Best For
Best for merchants who want complete control over their fraud filters and automated responses.
This app prevents theft of your store's content by disabling the right-click function. Note that this provides a vastly different function compared to FraudGuard.
Best For
Best for stores focused on protecting website content through basic measures.
Get comprehensive Shopify AI audits powered by advanced AI analysis. Perfect for brands and agencies looking to optimize their stores with actionable insights and data-driven recommendations.
AI SEO Audit
AI CRO Audit
App Audit
Mobile Experience
Page speed
Get Free Shopify AI Audit
Powered by AI. Reviewed by humans. Trusted by store owners.
25+ Shopify stores audited by AI so far.
4
Fraud Judge Fraud Prevention
5.0
4 reviews
Antifraud solution with ID & address verification, boosting chargeback protection and security.
Why Consider
Fraud Judge offers a similar rules-based system to FraudGuard, but explicitly mentions ID and address verification, providing customers a chance to prove the validity of a purchase. It also emphasizes chargeback protection and security through customized rules and real-time checks.
Best For
Best for merchants who need to verify customer identity and address to prevent fraud and chargebacks.
Verify COD orders with WhatsApp or SMS OTP and send instant order notifications to customers
Why Consider
If your store relies heavily on Cash on Delivery (COD) orders, OTP offers a very specialized feature that FraudGuard does not. It reduces fake COD orders and RTO by verifying purchases with OTP via WhatsApp, SMS, or email.
Best For
Ideal for stores that rely on Cash on Delivery and need to reduce fake orders.
AirLock: Your Ultimate Shield against IP-Based Threats.
Block unwanted visitors by IP and Country.
Why Consider
Airlock provides IP and Country blocking functionality that isn't explicitly stated in FraudGuard's feature list. If you're facing region-specific attacks or want to block specific IP addresses, Airlock provides a direct solution, with AI-enhanced detection and real-time visitor logs.
Best For
Best for merchants needing to block visitors based on IP address or geographical location.
Protecting your brand from return abuse and fraud.
Why Consider
Yofi specializes in preventing return fraud and policy abuse, offering a focused solution to a problem only indirectly addressed by FraudGuard. It uses AI to detect suspicious customer behaviors and provide CX reps with risk scores, allowing merchants to confidently manage refunds and optimize return policies.
Best For
Best for stores struggling with return fraud and policy abuse.
Get comprehensive Shopify AI audits powered by advanced AI analysis. Perfect for brands and agencies looking to optimize their stores with actionable insights and data-driven recommendations.
AI SEO Audit
AI CRO Audit
App Audit
Mobile Experience
Page speed
Get Free Shopify AI Audit
Powered by AI. Reviewed by humans. Trusted by store owners.
25+ Shopify stores audited by AI so far.
8
Deliverlitics: Stop Scammers
5.0
7 reviews
Catch delivery scams early. Block risky orders before they become chargebacks.
Why Consider
If your store struggles specifically with delivery scams and "friendly fraud," Deliverlitics offers a more focused approach than FraudGuard. It uses merchant-side data like returns and support messages to identify repeat offenders that traditional fraud filters might miss, offering automated actions to stop losses.
Best For
Best for merchants experiencing high rates of delivery scams and return fraud.
Easily verify the age of your customers. With our app, approve more orders and boost your sales!
Why Consider
Token of Trust specializes in age verification, a feature not directly addressed by FraudGuard. If you sell age-restricted products, Token of Trust offers tools to easily verify customer age and satisfy compliance mandates, remembering verified customers for faster future transactions.
Best For
Ideal for stores selling age-restricted products and requiring customer age verification.
Subuno helps you prevent credit card fraud/chargeback. Customize and automate your order screening.
Why Consider
Subuno presents itself as a customizable and automatable fraud prevention platform. It offers a more extensive set of manual review tools (15+) than FraudGuard, along with integrated third-party data analytics, to help merchants thoroughly assess suspicious orders and customize fraud checks without coding.
Best For
Best for merchants seeking a highly customizable fraud prevention platform with advanced data analytics.
Is there an alternative to FraudGuard that offers more comprehensive chargeback protection?
Yes, Chargeback Specialist specifically focuses on chargeback management, offering AI-powered dispute responses and human review to help recover lost revenue.
I'm primarily concerned about delivery fraud. Which alternative is best for that?
Deliverlitics: Stop Scammers is designed specifically to combat delivery scams and 'friendly fraud,' analyzing merchant-side data to identify repeat offenders.
Can I create my own fraud rules with any of these alternatives?
Yes, Fraud Falcon ‑ Block & Prevent, Fraud Judge Fraud Prevention, and Subuno all allow you to create custom fraud rules to automatically flag or block suspicious orders.
Do any of these alternatives offer customer age verification?
Token of Trust Verification specializes in age verification, which is essential if you sell age-restricted products.
I need to block specific countries or IP addresses. Which app can help me with that?
AirLock ‑ GeoShield & IP Block allows you to block unwanted visitors by IP address or country.
FixMyStore
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.