Afterpay On‑Site Messaging vs Koin Cashback & Store Creditfor Shopify (2026)
Afterpay On‑Site Messaging and Koin Cashback & Store Credit, while both falling under the 'Payments' category on Shopify, address entirely different needs. Afterpay aims to boost conversion rates by promoting Afterpay's buy-now-pay-later service on product and cart pages, specifically targeting Millennial and Gen Z shoppers. Its core strength lies in integrating Afterpay's branding into the merchant's storefront through customizable on-site messaging. This app is tailored towards merchants already using Afterpay and wanting to leverage it to attract younger demographics. Koin, on the other hand, focuses on customer retention and driving repeat purchases through a cashback and store credit system. It offers a suite of features to manage and distribute store credit, including automation through Shopify Flow, bulk editing, and promotional widgets. Koin targets merchants looking to implement loyalty programs, reward customer actions, or provide goodwill gestures. The app supports both D2C and B2B (Shopify Plus) businesses, offering flexibility in its application. Koin's value proposition revolves around increasing customer lifetime value and profitability through incentivized repeat purchases.
At a Glance
Afterpay On‑Site Messaging
46 reviews
Koin Cashback & Store Credit
57 reviews
Detailed Overview
Afterpay On‑Site Messaging
Convert more Next Gen shoppers with Afterpay’s On-Site Messaging App
Key Features
- Add messaging easily to product and cart pages with a visual editor
- Adjust mobile view, add footer icons, and personalize theme to match your brand
- Set minimum/maximum order limit messaging to match your account
Koin Cashback & Store Credit
Use native Store Credit to set cashback and rewards for any customer action that drives retention.
Key Features
- Set cashback rates by product/order, for D2C customers or B2B company locations
- Automate with pre-built Shopify Flow templates or create your own
- Bulk or single edit (credit/debit) store credit from customer accounts
- Promote rewards with widgets and send automated emails for store credit issuance
- Track and manage store credit effortlessly with intuitive dashboard
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 2.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Afterpay On‑Site Messaging2.9/5 Koin Cashback & Store Credit5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 46 | 57 |
Reviews Afterpay On‑Site Messaging46 Koin Cashback & Store Credit57 | ||
| Primary Goal | Increase conversion with Afterpay | Boost customer retention with store credit |
Primary Goal Afterpay On‑Site MessagingIncrease conversion with Afterpay Koin Cashback & Store CreditBoost customer retention with store credit | ||
| Target Audience | Merchants using Afterpay targeting Gen Z/Millennials | Merchants seeking loyalty programs (D2C & B2B) |
Target Audience Afterpay On‑Site MessagingMerchants using Afterpay targeting Gen Z/Millennials Koin Cashback & Store CreditMerchants seeking loyalty programs (D2C & B2B) | ||
| Key Functionality | Customizable Afterpay on-site messaging | Store credit management, cashback rewards |
Key Functionality Afterpay On‑Site MessagingCustomizable Afterpay on-site messaging Koin Cashback & Store CreditStore credit management, cashback rewards | ||
| Ease of Use (Implied) | Visual editor for messaging | Intuitive dashboard, Shopify Flow integration |
Ease of Use (Implied) Afterpay On‑Site MessagingVisual editor for messaging Koin Cashback & Store CreditIntuitive dashboard, Shopify Flow integration | ||
| Value Proposition | Attract Next Gen shoppers, faster checkouts | Increase customer lifetime value, repeat purchases |
Value Proposition Afterpay On‑Site MessagingAttract Next Gen shoppers, faster checkouts Koin Cashback & Store CreditIncrease customer lifetime value, repeat purchases | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants already offering Afterpay and primarily targeting Millennial and Gen Z demographics, Afterpay On‑Site Messaging provides a way to amplify the buy-now-pay-later option and potentially increase conversion rates. However, the significantly lower rating compared to Koin raises concerns about user experience and satisfaction.
Koin Cashback & Store Credit is the clear choice for merchants prioritizing customer retention and loyalty. Its high rating, combined with a comprehensive suite of features for managing store credit and automating rewards, makes it a robust solution for building long-term customer relationships and driving repeat purchases. Businesses operating on Shopify Plus and serving B2B clients will also find Koin's B2B support valuable.
Common Questions
Does Afterpay On‑Site Messaging manage payments?
No, it only promotes Afterpay as a payment option. Afterpay's payment processing must already be enabled on your store.
Can Koin be used without existing customer loyalty programs?
Yes, Koin is a standalone solution for creating and managing a store credit-based rewards system from scratch.
Is Afterpay On‑Site Messaging suitable for all product types?
It depends on whether your target demographic typically uses Afterpay for those products. High-value items might benefit more.
What level of coding knowledge is required for Koin's Shopify Flow integration?
Koin provides pre-built Shopify Flow templates, reducing the need for extensive coding knowledge. However, customizing flows may require some familiarity with Shopify Flow's interface.
How do I choose between these apps?
Choose Afterpay On-Site Messaging if you already offer Afterpay and want to boost conversion among Gen Z/Millennials. Choose Koin if you want to create a customer loyalty program based on store credit.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store