All in gift vs CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYfor Shopify (2026)
All in gift and CartKing-Free Gifts BuyX GetY are both highly rated Shopify apps (4.9/5) in the Gifts category. However, they target different aspects of gifting and offer distinct functionalities. All in gift focuses on comprehensive gifting solutions tailored to Japanese market conventions, including features like 'e-gifts', specialized wrapping options, multi-shipping, and catalogue gifts. Its strength lies in facilitating a richer, more culturally nuanced gifting experience, including anonymous gifting and integrations with fulfillment apps. CartKing, conversely, concentrates on promotional gifting to increase Average Order Value (AOV). It automates the process of adding free gifts to carts based on defined rules and offers features like 'Buy X Get Y' deals, tiered gifts, and customizable banners. Its target audience is merchants who want to leverage gifting as a direct sales driver, offering promotions at checkout and on product pages. The app is designed for simplicity and aims to encourage immediate purchases through enticing gift offers.
At a Glance
All in gift
132 reviews
CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY
96 reviews
Detailed Overview
All in gift
お届け先を指定する「通常ギフト」も、住所がわからない人にも贈れる「eギフト」もこのアプリ1つで対応。熨斗やラッピング、カタログギフト、配送分割（マルチシップ）も対応、リッチなギフト設定が実現できます。
Key Features
- 熨斗、ラッピング、ギフトカード、手提げ袋など日本の商習慣に合わせたギフトオプション対応設定
- 住所を知らない相手にも気軽にギフトが贈れるeギフト（SNSギフト）の受取り URL の発行
- 有名人やインフルエンサーにもギフトを贈れる、お届先住所の匿名化
- ロジレス・オープンロジ・ネクストエンジンなどの各種出荷業務アプリとも連携（今後も連携数拡大予定）
- 受取手の好みが分からない場合も大丈夫、ギフトの受取手が商品を選べるカタログギフト機能
CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY
Now, unlock Free gift with Purchase, Auto add to Cart, Buy X Get Y, Tired Gifts, BOGO
Key Features
- Auto-add free gifts with purchase when cart meets your rules
- Show multiple free gift options in cart and cart drawer
- Run multi-gift, tiered gifts and buy X get Y gift campaigns
- Customize gift banners to match your theme and run them with other discounts
- Announce free gift offers on product pages to encourage customers to add to cart
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating All in gift4.9/5 CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 132 | 96 |
Reviews All in gift132 CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY96 | ||
| Focus | Comprehensive Gifting (Japanese Market) | Promotional Gifting (AOV Booster) |
Focus All in giftComprehensive Gifting (Japanese Market) CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYPromotional Gifting (AOV Booster) | ||
| Key Features | E-gifts, Wrapping Options, Multi-Shipping, Catalogue Gifts, Address Anonymization | Auto-add Gifts, Buy X Get Y, Tiered Gifts, Customizable Banners |
Key Features All in giftE-gifts, Wrapping Options, Multi-Shipping, Catalogue Gifts, Address Anonymization CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYAuto-add Gifts, Buy X Get Y, Tiered Gifts, Customizable Banners | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants targeting the Japanese market or needing complex gifting options | Merchants focused on increasing AOV through promotions |
Target Merchant All in giftMerchants targeting the Japanese market or needing complex gifting options CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYMerchants focused on increasing AOV through promotions | ||
| Integration Focus | Fulfillment Apps (Logiles, Openlogi, Next Engine) | Theme Customization (Banners, Widgets) |
Integration Focus All in giftFulfillment Apps (Logiles, Openlogi, Next Engine) CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYTheme Customization (Banners, Widgets) | ||
| Gift Recipient Choice | Catalogue Gifts (Recipient chooses) | Multiple gift options shown in cart/drawer |
Gift Recipient Choice All in giftCatalogue Gifts (Recipient chooses) CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYMultiple gift options shown in cart/drawer | ||
| Value Proposition | Enhanced customer experience through diverse and culturally relevant gifting options. | Directly increase sales by automatically offering free gifts. |
Value Proposition All in giftEnhanced customer experience through diverse and culturally relevant gifting options. CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYDirectly increase sales by automatically offering free gifts. | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants specifically targeting the Japanese market, or those needing highly customizable gifting options like personalized wrapping, catalogue gifts, and address anonymization, All in gift is the clear choice. Its focus on cultural nuances and complex fulfillment makes it ideal for businesses looking to offer a premium gifting experience.
However, if the primary goal is to boost AOV and drive immediate sales through promotional gifting, CartKing-Free Gifts BuyX GetY is the better option. Its ease of use in setting up automated gift offers and its focus on checkout promotions makes it a more effective tool for directly influencing purchase decisions. CartKing is also easier to use in terms of getting started quickly to increase sales. It is better suited for merchants looking to implement straightforward promotional gifting strategies without complex customization requirements.
Common Questions
Which app is better for targeting the Japanese market?
All in gift is specifically designed for the Japanese market, offering features aligned with Japanese gifting customs.
Which app is easier to set up and start using immediately?
CartKing-Free Gifts BuyX GetY is designed for quick setup and immediate implementation of promotional gift offers.
Which app is better for complex gifting scenarios?
All in gift, with its multi-shipping, catalogue gifts, and address anonymization, is better suited for complex gifting requirements.
Which app focuses more on increasing average order value (AOV)?
CartKing-Free Gifts BuyX GetY directly focuses on increasing AOV through promotional gifting strategies.
Do both apps offer free gift options?
Yes, both apps provide functionality for offering free gifts, but in different ways. All in gift might include free gift wrapping with purchase. CartKing uses automation to provide free gifts.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store