AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO vs Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGOfor Shopify (2026)
In 2026, both AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO and Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO compete in the Shopify app market, aiming to increase average order value and customer engagement through free gift and BOGO promotions. AppHero positions itself as a solution with strategic free gift offers triggered by cart value, quantity, or specific products, emphasizing personalized campaigns with features like language options and customer segmentation. Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO, on the other hand, focuses on ease of use and quick setup, promoting itself as an all-in-one solution built for fast implementation of BOGO deals and free gift boxes. While AppHero highlights advanced targeting and scheduling capabilities, the Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO app emphasizes its 'EasyGift' logic for simplified offer creation and management. The primary difference lies in the user experience and feature prioritization. AppHero caters to merchants seeking deeper customization and campaign personalization, whereas Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO targets users prioritizing a fast and straightforward setup process. The review volume heavily favors Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO, suggesting broader adoption and more established user feedback despite a slightly lower average rating.
At a Glance
AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO
3 reviews
Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO
142 reviews
Detailed Overview
AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO
Encourage Larger Orders with Strategic Free Gift Offers: Auto Add to Cart, Buy X Get Y, BOGO & More!
Key Features
- Add gifts to cart based on total cart value, cart quantity, or specific products
- Allow customers to select their preferred free gift from multiple options
- Promote gift offers with attractive product page banners & widget notifications
- Advanced targeting with language options and customer segmentation features
- Effortlessly run & schedule multiple gift & BOGO offers during special occasions
Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO
Drive More Sales with Free Gifts, BOGO Deals & Gift Boxes.
Key Features
- Auto Add Gifts to Cart – Set rules like buy x get y or buy 1 get 1 free.
- Showcase a Free Gift Box – Let customers choose their free gift easily.
- Quick Setup with EasyGift Logic – Launch offers in under 2 minutes.
- Support Buy 2 Get 1, BOGO & More – Flexible rules, no code needed.
- Ideal for Shopify stores offering free gifts, BOGO, and automatic discounts.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO5/5 Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 3 | 142 |
Reviews AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO3 Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO142 | ||
| Key Differentiator | Advanced Targeting & Scheduling | 'EasyGift' Logic & Quick Setup |
Key Differentiator AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGOAdvanced Targeting & Scheduling Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO'EasyGift' Logic & Quick Setup | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants needing personalized campaigns & advanced segmentation | Merchants seeking a simple, fast setup for common free gift promos |
Target Merchant AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGOMerchants needing personalized campaigns & advanced segmentation Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGOMerchants seeking a simple, fast setup for common free gift promos | ||
| Ease of Use | Intuitive Setup, but potentially more complex customization | Very Quick Setup (under 2 minutes) with EasyGift Logic |
Ease of Use AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGOIntuitive Setup, but potentially more complex customization Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGOVery Quick Setup (under 2 minutes) with EasyGift Logic | ||
| Value Proposition | Strategic, personalized gift offers to maximize AOV. | Simplified free gift & BOGO promotions for increased conversions. |
Value Proposition AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGOStrategic, personalized gift offers to maximize AOV. Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGOSimplified free gift & BOGO promotions for increased conversions. | ||
| Customization | High (language options, customer segmentation) | Full customization, but focus on simpler configurations |
Customization AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGOHigh (language options, customer segmentation) Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGOFull customization, but focus on simpler configurations | ||
| Gift Selection by Customer | Customers can select preferred free gift | Showcase a Free Gift Box – Let customers choose their free gift easily. |
Gift Selection by Customer AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGOCustomers can select preferred free gift Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGOShowcase a Free Gift Box – Let customers choose their free gift easily. | ||
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants prioritizing a quick and easy setup for common free gift and BOGO promotions, Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO appears to be the stronger choice, given its substantial user base and focus on 'EasyGift' logic. The slightly lower rating is mitigated by the significantly higher review count, providing more confidence in its reliability.
However, merchants who require more granular control over their gift campaigns, including advanced targeting, language options, and customer segmentation, may find AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO to be the better fit. The 5-star rating, while based on a small sample, suggests high satisfaction among its initial users, but the app's relative newness necessitates careful consideration and monitoring of future reviews. If extensive customization is a must-have and a slightly steeper learning curve is acceptable, AppHero could be the more suitable option.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up and get running?
Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO emphasizes its 'EasyGift' logic and claims a setup time of under 2 minutes, suggesting it's the quicker option to get started with.
Which app offers more control over targeting specific customer segments?
AppHero: Free Gift Upsell BOGO explicitly mentions 'Advanced targeting with language options and customer segmentation features', indicating more refined control over target audiences.
Does either app support Buy 2 Get 1 free promotions?
Yes, Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO specifically states support for 'Buy 2 Get 1, BOGO & More – Flexible rules, no code needed.'
If I want customers to choose their free gift, which app is better?
Both apps enable customers to choose their free gift, with AppHero letting 'customers to select their preferred free gift from multiple options' and Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO letting users 'Showcase a Free Gift Box – Let customers choose their free gift easily.'
Which app has more user feedback and a longer track record?
Free Gift Box+Buy 1 Get 1+BOGO has significantly more reviews (142) compared to AppHero (3), indicating a longer track record and a larger user base providing feedback.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store