CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY vs Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑onefor Shopify (2026)
CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY and Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑one are both Shopify apps aimed at enhancing sales through gifting, but they approach it from fundamentally different angles. CartKing focuses on boosting Average Order Value (AOV) by offering free gifts with purchase, BOGO deals, and other promotional incentives directly integrated into the shopping cart and checkout experience. Its strength lies in driving immediate sales by rewarding customers for meeting purchase thresholds. In contrast, Gift Card Hero focuses on providing a comprehensive gift card solution, encompassing custom designs, reloadable balances, physical and digital gift card options, and features like video greetings. It aims at fostering long-term customer relationships and acquiring new customers through personalized gifting experiences.
At a Glance
CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY
96 reviews
Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑one
134 reviews
Detailed Overview
CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY
Now, unlock Free gift with Purchase, Auto add to Cart, Buy X Get Y, Tired Gifts, BOGO
Key Features
- Auto-add free gifts with purchase when cart meets your rules
- Show multiple free gift options in cart and cart drawer
- Run multi-gift, tiered gifts and buy X get Y gift campaigns
- Customize gift banners to match your theme and run them with other discounts
- Announce free gift offers on product pages to encourage customers to add to cart
Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑one
The all-in-one app for customisable, reloadable gift cards! New feature: Video greetings!
Key Features
- Gift card schedule send. Video greetings
- Bulk tools (import, generator, update, mass send) via csv files
- Gift card balance top-up/reload. Gift card balance check widget
- Unused balance reminders.
- Easy one click setup, fast support, design customisations, API for devs.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY4.9/5 Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑one5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 96 | 134 |
Reviews CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY96 Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑one134 | ||
| Primary Function | Free Gifts and Promotions (BOGO, Buy X Get Y) | Gift Card Management (eGift cards, physical cards, balance top-up) |
Primary Function CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYFree Gifts and Promotions (BOGO, Buy X Get Y) Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑oneGift Card Management (eGift cards, physical cards, balance top-up) | ||
| Key Differentiator | Auto-add free gifts and tiered gift campaigns | All-in-one gift card system with video greetings and balance top-up |
Key Differentiator CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYAuto-add free gifts and tiered gift campaigns Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑oneAll-in-one gift card system with video greetings and balance top-up | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants focused on increasing AOV through promotions | Merchants focused on customer loyalty, seasonal sales, and brand building through gifting |
Target Merchant Type CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYMerchants focused on increasing AOV through promotions Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑oneMerchants focused on customer loyalty, seasonal sales, and brand building through gifting | ||
| Ease of Use | Customize gift banners; live chat support | One-click setup; design customisations; API access |
Ease of Use CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYCustomize gift banners; live chat support Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑oneOne-click setup; design customisations; API access | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase sales by incentivizing larger purchases | Boost revenue, build customer relationships, acquire new customers through gift cards |
Value Proposition CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYIncrease sales by incentivizing larger purchases Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑oneBoost revenue, build customer relationships, acquire new customers through gift cards | ||
| Pricing Model | Likely tiered; description mentions 'Free' | Likely tiered; implied functionality suggests paid tiers |
Pricing Model CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetYLikely tiered; description mentions 'Free' Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑oneLikely tiered; implied functionality suggests paid tiers | ||
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants primarily interested in immediately boosting AOV through promotional offers like free gifts and BOGO deals, CartKing‑Free Gifts BuyX GetY appears to be the more suitable option. Its focus on cart-based incentives and automated gift offers aligns directly with this goal. However, if the primary objective is to create a robust gift card program, encompassing both digital and physical cards, personalized options, and tools for managing gift card balances and customer engagement, then Gift Card Hero • All‑in‑one is the clearly superior choice. Its comprehensive feature set addresses the full lifecycle of gift card sales and redemption. A merchant could potentially use both apps; CartKing for promotional surges and Gift Card Hero for evergreen gift card sales and customer retention.
Common Questions
What's the main difference between the two apps?
CartKing focuses on immediate sales increases through promotional gifts and offers, while Gift Card Hero focuses on long-term revenue generation and customer relationship building via a comprehensive gift card system.
Which app is easier to set up?
Gift Card Hero explicitly claims 'easy one-click setup,' suggesting it might be quicker to get started with, while CartKing requires configuration of rules for triggering free gifts.
Which app is better for acquiring new customers?
Gift Card Hero is likely better for acquiring new customers through gift card sales, which can introduce new individuals to a brand. CartKing can indirectly acquire new customers by incentivizing existing ones to share promotional offers with friends.
Can I use both apps together?
Yes, the apps serve different purposes. CartKing can be used for short-term sales boosts, while Gift Card Hero can provide a continuous stream of revenue through gift card sales. They don't directly compete.
Which app is better for promoting seasonal holidays?
While both apps can be used, Gift Card Hero specifically mentions 'Grow revenue during seasonal holidays,' suggesting it has features tailored for holiday gift card sales. CartKing could also be used by creating holiday-themed gift offers.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store