Catalog Maker by Now in Store vs Claimbase: Instagram Salesfor Shopify (2026)
In 2026, merchants choosing between Catalog Maker by Now in Store and Claimbase: Instagram Sales face a classic dilemma of popularity versus high praise. Catalog Maker, with a 3.9/5 rating from 92 reviews, suggests a broader user base and potentially more diverse functionality aimed at wider catalog management or advertising related tasks. The sheer volume of reviews could indicate a longer market presence and more feature breadth. Claimbase: Instagram Sales, on the other hand, boasts a perfect 5/5 rating, though based on only 15 reviews. This points to highly satisfied but likely a smaller, more niche user group focused specifically on integrating with Instagram for sales. The 'Instagram Sales' title highlights a focus on social commerce, a key differentiator. Catalog Maker’s relatively lower rating, despite many more reviews, might imply a steeper learning curve, bugs encountered by some users, or a broader feature set that not everyone finds valuable. Claimbase, with a smaller review pool, could signify a newer app, a simpler user experience, or a highly targeted function that resonates strongly with its specific audience – those leveraging Instagram for sales and desiring straightforward, well-executed integration. Therefore, the choice hinges on the merchant's specific needs: a general catalog solution or a dedicated Instagram sales tool.
At a Glance
Catalog Maker by Now in Store
92 reviews
Claimbase: Instagram Sales
15 reviews
Detailed Overview
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 3.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Catalog Maker by Now in Store3.9/5 Claimbase: Instagram Sales5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 92 | 15 |
Reviews Catalog Maker by Now in Store92 Claimbase: Instagram Sales15 | ||
| Primary Function | Catalog Management/Advertising (General) | Instagram Sales Integration |
Primary Function Catalog Maker by Now in StoreCatalog Management/Advertising (General) Claimbase: Instagram SalesInstagram Sales Integration | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants with diverse catalog needs and larger product ranges requiring advertising outside of Instagram | Merchants primarily focused on selling via Instagram and needing direct sales integration |
Target Merchant Catalog Maker by Now in StoreMerchants with diverse catalog needs and larger product ranges requiring advertising outside of Instagram Claimbase: Instagram SalesMerchants primarily focused on selling via Instagram and needing direct sales integration | ||
| Ease of Use (Likely) | Potentially more complex due to broader functionality | Likely simpler and more streamlined, focused on Instagram |
Ease of Use (Likely) Catalog Maker by Now in StorePotentially more complex due to broader functionality Claimbase: Instagram SalesLikely simpler and more streamlined, focused on Instagram | ||
| Value Proposition | Comprehensive catalog management and diverse advertising capabilities, potentially with a steeper learning curve. | Simplified Instagram sales process and direct integration, ideal for social commerce specialists. |
Value Proposition Catalog Maker by Now in StoreComprehensive catalog management and diverse advertising capabilities, potentially with a steeper learning curve. Claimbase: Instagram SalesSimplified Instagram sales process and direct integration, ideal for social commerce specialists. | ||
| Market Presence (Likely) | Longer market presence indicated by higher number of reviews | Potentially newer app with a smaller, more focused user base |
Market Presence (Likely) Catalog Maker by Now in StoreLonger market presence indicated by higher number of reviews Claimbase: Instagram SalesPotentially newer app with a smaller, more focused user base | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants heavily reliant on Instagram as a primary sales channel and prioritizing seamless social commerce integration, Claimbase: Instagram Sales appears to be the superior choice, despite the smaller number of reviews. The perfect rating suggests a highly effective and well-received solution for its target audience. If, however, a merchant requires a more comprehensive catalog management solution with broader advertising functionalities, and is willing to potentially navigate a steeper learning curve and account for some less-than-perfect user experiences, Catalog Maker by Now in Store might be more suitable.
Ultimately, the decision depends on whether the business's focus lies on dedicated Instagram sales or broader catalog and advertising needs. Those who primarily sell on Instagram will find Claimbase: Instagram Sales more beneficial, while businesses with diversified sales channels will benefit from the Catalog Maker.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up and use?
Based on the rating and reviews, Claimbase: Instagram Sales is likely easier to set up and use, due to its specific focus on Instagram sales. Catalog Maker's broader feature set might lead to a more complex setup process.
Which app is better for a merchant with a large product catalog?
Catalog Maker, due to its broader functionality, is potentially better suited for managing a large product catalog, though it would require more investigation into the details of its catalog management features.
Which app is more reliable?
Reliability is difficult to determine without more data. The lower rating of Catalog Maker may indicate more bugs or issues, but the higher number of reviews could simply represent a larger user base encountering diverse situations. Further investigation into individual user reviews is necessary.
Which app is better for a merchant just starting out?
Claimbase: Instagram Sales is potentially better for a new merchant focused on building an audience and sales primarily through Instagram. Its simplicity and targeted functionality would offer a more streamlined start.
What are the key differences in support documentation for these apps?
Without access to the app descriptions in the Shopify App Store, we can't determine the support documentation differences. Merchants should check the documentation before making a final decision. Look for comprehensive help articles, video tutorials, and responsive support teams.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store