Categories Uncomplicated vs PH Breadcrumbsfor Shopify (2026)
Both Categories Uncomplicated and PH Breadcrumbs aim to improve navigation and SEO for Shopify stores through categories and breadcrumbs. However, they approach this goal with different scopes and emphasis. Categories Uncomplicated focuses on creating a comprehensive category structure, allowing merchants to organize collections into hierarchical categories with visuals like icons and breadcrumbs, even offering integration with Shopify Translate & Adapt. It builds on the existing Shopify navigation system and incorporates dynamic JSON-LD for enhanced SEO. This makes it a strong contender for stores needing a robust, visually driven category organization. PH Breadcrumbs, on the other hand, prioritizes SEO by creating breadcrumb navigation based on menu structure and leveraging JSON-LD schema. Its primary strength lies in its highly customizable breadcrumb navigation and easy setup with global settings. PH Breadcrumbs emphasizes the automatic generation of breadcrumbs from menu structure, making it a potentially easier solution for merchants who already have a well-defined menu hierarchy. It might be more appealing to those primarily concerned with SEO and having a straightforward breadcrumb implementation.
At a Glance
Categories Uncomplicated
36 reviews
PH Breadcrumbs
17 reviews
Detailed Overview
Categories Uncomplicated
Simply add categories to your store's collections
Key Features
- Create categories and sub-categories that work with Shopify Translate & Adapt
- Use the existing standard Shopify navigation system to define your categories
- Improve the SEO metadata that you're sending to Google with dynamic JSON-LD
- Drag-and-drop install using Shopify 2.0 themes, or code into older 1.0 themes
- 2-in-1 bundle of products including category breadcrumbs and sub-category icons
PH Breadcrumbs
Add JSON+LD Schema & breadcrumbs based on menu structure. Add breadcrumb hierarchy on product pages.
Key Features
- Allows for multi-level SEO JSON-LD breadcrumb.
- Allows huge number of customizations to breadcrumb navigation.
- Add breadcrumb navigation based on menu structure.
- Improves SEO by creating JSON+LD BreadcrumbList Schema based on menu structure.
- Easy, fast setup with global settings, allow you to set once and use everywhere.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Categories Uncomplicated5/5 PH Breadcrumbs5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 36 | 17 |
Reviews Categories Uncomplicated36 PH Breadcrumbs17 | ||
| Primary Focus | Comprehensive Category Organization & Visualization | SEO-Focused Breadcrumb Navigation |
Primary Focus Categories UncomplicatedComprehensive Category Organization & Visualization PH BreadcrumbsSEO-Focused Breadcrumb Navigation | ||
| Category Structure | Hierarchical Categories & Sub-categories | Based on Menu Structure |
Category Structure Categories UncomplicatedHierarchical Categories & Sub-categories PH BreadcrumbsBased on Menu Structure | ||
| SEO Enhancement | Dynamic JSON-LD | JSON+LD BreadcrumbList Schema |
SEO Enhancement Categories UncomplicatedDynamic JSON-LD PH BreadcrumbsJSON+LD BreadcrumbList Schema | ||
| Ease of Use | Drag-and-drop install (2.0 themes), or code (1.0 themes) | Easy, fast setup with global settings |
Ease of Use Categories UncomplicatedDrag-and-drop install (2.0 themes), or code (1.0 themes) PH BreadcrumbsEasy, fast setup with global settings | ||
| Customization | Limited customization, focuses on structure | Numerous config options for breadcrumb navigation |
Customization Categories UncomplicatedLimited customization, focuses on structure PH BreadcrumbsNumerous config options for breadcrumb navigation | ||
| Key Features | Category breadcrumbs, sub-category icons, Translate & Adapt compatibility | Multi-level SEO JSON-LD breadcrumb, HTML breadcrumb rendering |
Key Features Categories UncomplicatedCategory breadcrumbs, sub-category icons, Translate & Adapt compatibility PH BreadcrumbsMulti-level SEO JSON-LD breadcrumb, HTML breadcrumb rendering | ||
Our Verdict
Categories Uncomplicated is the better choice for merchants needing a comprehensive solution to organize their product catalogs into categories and sub-categories with visual aids. Its strength lies in creating a well-defined hierarchy and supporting translation. This app is ideal if you need a structured approach to collections beyond simple menus.
PH Breadcrumbs is more suitable for merchants whose main goal is to improve SEO through optimized breadcrumbs and who want a simpler setup process. If you already have a good menu structure and you're looking for a straightforward way to implement breadcrumbs with robust customization options and SEO focus, PH Breadcrumbs will likely be more appealing. Choose PH Breadcrumbs if SEO is your top priority.
Common Questions
Which app provides a more customizable breadcrumb experience?
PH Breadcrumbs provides more numerous config options to customize the look and feel of your breadcrumb navigation.
Which app focuses more on the overall category organization?
Categories Uncomplicated offers a more comprehensive approach to category organization, including sub-categories and visual elements such as icons.
Which app is easier to set up for stores with older (1.0) Shopify themes?
Categories Uncomplicated requires code integration for older themes, while PH Breadcrumbs emphasizes easy setup regardless of theme version. Therefore, PH Breadcrumbs would likely be easier for older themes.
Which app offers translation compatibility for categories?
Categories Uncomplicated explicitly states compatibility with Shopify Translate & Adapt, while PH Breadcrumbs does not mention this feature.
Which app generates breadcrumbs in HTML?
PH Breadcrumbs breadcrumb navigation is generated in HTML, not JavaScript.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store