Gift Box • Gift with Purchase vs Givy → Gift Cards & Giftsfor Shopify (2026)
Gift Box • Gift with Purchase and Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts both cater to the 'Gifts' category on Shopify, but they address distinct merchant needs. Gift Box focuses on incentivizing purchases through strategies like Buy-One-Get-One (BOGO) offers, free gifts with purchase, and spend-based rewards. It emphasizes ease of use and quick implementation, aiming to boost sales and customer loyalty through strategic gift promotions. The app is designed for merchants who want a simple and effective way to increase average order value and reward customers for specific purchasing behaviors. In contrast, Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts provides a comprehensive gifting solution, enabling merchants to sell multi-currency gift cards, offer product and subscription gifting options, and personalize the gifting experience with messages, gift wrapping, and scheduled delivery. It caters to a broader range of gifting scenarios, including corporate gifting, bulk voucher distribution, and influencer seeding. Givy is ideal for merchants looking to create a sophisticated gifting experience that extends beyond simple purchase incentives. It aims to increase sales and foster customer loyalty through enhanced gifting flexibility and customization, including support for subscriptions and corporate gifting initiatives.
At a Glance
Gift Box • Gift with Purchase
178 reviews
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts
32 reviews
Detailed Overview
Gift Box • Gift with Purchase
Motivate your customers to spend more with free gift with purchase (GWP) & BOGO offers.
Key Features
- Gift Rules – Set rules like Spend X, Buy X Get Y, or Collection-based
- Auto Add to Cart – Add free gifts automatically (optional)
- Fast & Easy – Launch gift offers in minutes, no coding needed
- Mobile Friendly – Smooth, responsive gift offers on all devices
- Multi-language – Popup now translatable via Shopify Translate app
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts
Multi currency gift cards, product & subscription gifting, wrapping, corporate gifts, bulk vouchers
Key Features
- Product gifting → enable gifting on any product, send gift card as a gift
- Custom gift card amounts → sell gift cards with fixed or custom denominations
- Bulk gift cards & campaigns → email or print gift cards for loyal customers
- Multi-currency gift cards → buy and redeem gift cards in multiple currencies
- Subscription & membership gifting → recipients become subscribers automatically!
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.8/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Gift Box • Gift with Purchase4.8/5 Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 178 | 32 |
Reviews Gift Box • Gift with Purchase178 Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts32 | ||
| Core Functionality | Gift with Purchase & BOGO | Gift Cards & Product/Subscription Gifting |
Core Functionality Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseGift with Purchase & BOGO Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsGift Cards & Product/Subscription Gifting | ||
| Ease of Use | Emphasis on quick setup and no coding | Not explicitly mentioned, implied complexity with broader feature set |
Ease of Use Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseEmphasis on quick setup and no coding Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsNot explicitly mentioned, implied complexity with broader feature set | ||
| Currency Support | Not mentioned | Multi-currency gift cards |
Currency Support Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseNot mentioned Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsMulti-currency gift cards | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants seeking simple purchase incentives | Merchants wanting a comprehensive gifting solution (incl. corporate gifting) |
Target Merchant Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseMerchants seeking simple purchase incentives Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsMerchants wanting a comprehensive gifting solution (incl. corporate gifting) | ||
| Subscription Gifting | Not Supported | Supported |
Subscription Gifting Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseNot Supported Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsSupported | ||
| Corporate Gifting | Not Supported | Supported |
Corporate Gifting Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseNot Supported Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsSupported | ||
| Key Value Proposition | Increase average order value and reward specific purchase behavior | Enhanced gifting flexibility, customer loyalty, and support for complex gifting scenarios |
Key Value Proposition Gift Box • Gift with PurchaseIncrease average order value and reward specific purchase behavior Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsEnhanced gifting flexibility, customer loyalty, and support for complex gifting scenarios | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily interested in quickly implementing gift-with-purchase or BOGO offers to boost sales, Gift Box • Gift with Purchase is the better choice. Its focus on simplicity and ease of use allows for rapid deployment of targeted campaigns. The higher review count, despite the slightly lower rating, suggests greater usage and a more established user base.
However, if a merchant requires a more comprehensive gifting solution, including multi-currency gift cards, subscription gifting, and corporate gifting capabilities, Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts is the superior option. Its robust feature set allows for a more sophisticated and personalized gifting experience. While it has fewer reviews, the perfect 5/5 rating suggests high customer satisfaction among its user base, potentially indicating a smaller but highly engaged user community.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up and use?
Gift Box • Gift with Purchase emphasizes ease of use, stating that gift offers can be launched in minutes without coding. Givy doesn't explicitly mention ease of use, but its wider range of features likely implies a steeper learning curve.
Which app supports multi-currency transactions?
Givy supports multi-currency gift cards, allowing customers to buy and redeem gift cards in multiple currencies. Gift Box does not explicitly mention currency support.
Which app is better for running promotions to increase average order value?
Gift Box is specifically designed to increase average order value with features like Spend X, Buy X Get Y offers. Givy focuses more on general gifting functionalities.
Which app allows customers to gift subscriptions?
Givy enables customers to gift subscriptions, which automatically enrolls the recipient as a subscriber. Gift Box does not support subscription gifting.
Which app is more suitable for corporate gifting programs?
Givy specifically supports corporate gifting, allowing merchants to create and distribute bulk gift cards and vouchers. Gift Box does not offer corporate gifting features.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store