Gift Wrap Plus vs Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Messagefor Shopify (2026)
Gift Wrap Plus and Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message, both offer gift wrap solutions for Shopify merchants in 2026, but they target different needs and offer distinct feature sets. Gift Wrap Plus positions itself as a straightforward, easy-to-install solution to add basic gift wrapping functionality to a Shopify store, filling a gap in Shopify's native features. Its strength lies in its simplicity and targeted feature set for product and collection-level gift wrap application. It would be suitable for smaller stores looking for a quick and affordable solution. Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message, on the other hand, aims to provide a more comprehensive and integrated gifting experience. While Gift Wrap Plus focuses mainly on gift wrapping, Super goes further by offering personalized notes, upsell opportunities, and integration with external platforms. Its strengths are its wider range of features, including order tagging and checkout add-ons, which enable advanced marketing and fulfillment processes. Super seems better positioned for stores with higher order volume and those looking to fully optimize gifting as a revenue and customer experience driver, especially larger stores needing integration and reporting features.
At a Glance
Gift Wrap Plus
69 reviews
Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message
230 reviews
Detailed Overview
Gift Wrap Plus
Creating gift wraps in your store allows you to offer your customers more than just a product.
Key Features
- Create Gift Wrap for choice of Collections Only
- Easy to install Gift Wrap Plus, no code knowledge required.
- See Stats of your best performing gift wraps and other activities.
- Create Gift Wrap for All Store Products
- Create a Gift Wrap for specific Products Only
Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message
Turn orders into memories with gift wraps & note options, for supreme high-value checkout experience
Key Features
- Add multiple gift options to product pages, checkout, cart, drawer & boost AOV
- Show the gift options add on in your Plus Checkout page for maximum awareness
- Automatic gift orders tags for fulfillment, filtering, and tracking insights
- Boost conversions: Product/based targeting for smarter upsell offers
- Support orders from Roposo, GlowRoad, GiftShip, FlipKart, Raffle giveaway & more
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Gift Wrap Plus4.9/5 Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 69 | 230 |
Reviews Gift Wrap Plus69 Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message230 | ||
| Primary Focus | Simple Gift Wrapping | Comprehensive Gifting Experience (Wraps, Messages, Upsells) |
Primary Focus Gift Wrap PlusSimple Gift Wrapping Super: Gift Wrap, Gift MessageComprehensive Gifting Experience (Wraps, Messages, Upsells) | ||
| Ease of Use | Easy install, no code knowledge required | 1-click setup |
Ease of Use Gift Wrap PlusEasy install, no code knowledge required Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message1-click setup | ||
| Advanced Features | Basic Reporting Stats | Order Tagging, Plus Checkout Integration, External Platform Support |
Advanced Features Gift Wrap PlusBasic Reporting Stats Super: Gift Wrap, Gift MessageOrder Tagging, Plus Checkout Integration, External Platform Support | ||
| Target Merchant | Small to Medium Stores, Budget-Conscious | Medium to Large Stores, Focus on AOV & Customer Experience |
Target Merchant Gift Wrap PlusSmall to Medium Stores, Budget-Conscious Super: Gift Wrap, Gift MessageMedium to Large Stores, Focus on AOV & Customer Experience | ||
| Gift Wrap Location | Product/Collection Level | Product Pages, Checkout, Cart, Drawer |
Gift Wrap Location Gift Wrap PlusProduct/Collection Level Super: Gift Wrap, Gift MessageProduct Pages, Checkout, Cart, Drawer | ||
| Upselling | Not Specified | Product-Based Targeting for Upsell Offers |
Upselling Gift Wrap PlusNot Specified Super: Gift Wrap, Gift MessageProduct-Based Targeting for Upsell Offers | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking a straightforward and affordable solution to simply add gift wrapping to their store, especially those with limited technical expertise or a small product catalog, Gift Wrap Plus is a good choice. Its emphasis on ease of use and simple configuration makes it quick to implement.
For larger businesses that view gifting as a crucial aspect of customer experience and want to leverage it for increased AOV and advanced fulfillment, Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message is the better option. Its wider range of features, including order tagging, upsell capabilities, and integration with checkout flows and external platforms, provides the flexibility needed for scaling and optimizing the gifting experience.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Both apps claim ease of setup. Gift Wrap Plus highlights its lack of code requirement, while Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message, boasts a 1-click setup. Actual ease may depend on the merchant's technical skill and specific store configuration.
Which app offers more advanced reporting?
Gift Wrap Plus offers basic stats on gift wrap performance. Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message, enables automatic gift order tags for fulfillment, filtering, and tracking insights, indicating more comprehensive reporting capabilities.
Which app is better for increasing Average Order Value (AOV)?
Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message, is likely more effective at increasing AOV due to its focus on upsell opportunities and checkout integration.
Which app supports integration with more platforms?
Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message, supports orders from Roposo, GlowRoad, GiftShip, FlipKart, Raffle giveaway & more, whereas Gift Wrap Plus does not explicitly mention integrations with external platforms.
Which app is a better long-term investment for a growing Shopify store?
While Gift Wrap Plus can be suitable initially, Super: Gift Wrap, Gift Message's scalability and robust features will be more valuable as the store grows and requires more advanced gifting and marketing capabilities.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store