Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts vs Insertr: Marketing Automationfor Shopify (2026)
Givy and Insertr, while both in the 'Gifts' category on Shopify, cater to fundamentally different needs. Givy focuses on expanding a merchant's gifting options, allowing for the sale of gift cards (including multi-currency options), product gifting, subscription gifting, and corporate gifting solutions. Its strength lies in its comprehensive gifting features, including customizable amounts, bulk generation, and integration with physical gift cards. Insertr, on the other hand, is a marketing automation tool specifically designed for physical inserts. It allows merchants to automate the inclusion of free samples, thank you cards, and promotional flyers into orders based on customizable rules. The core difference lies in their purpose. Givy aims to enhance the shopping experience by offering diverse gifting opportunities and increased revenue streams through gift card sales. Insertr focuses on optimizing order fulfillment by using physical inserts to drive conversions, upsells, and improved customer loyalty through targeted marketing materials. One app deals with virtual gifts and the sales process, while the other deals with physical marketing after a purchase has been made.
At a Glance
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts
32 reviews
Insertr: Marketing Automation
4 reviews
Detailed Overview
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts
Multi currency gift cards, product & subscription gifting, wrapping, corporate gifts, bulk vouchers
Key Features
- Product gifting → enable gifting on any product, send gift card as a gift
- Custom gift card amounts → sell gift cards with fixed or custom denominations
- Bulk gift cards & campaigns → email or print gift cards for loyal customers
- Multi-currency gift cards → buy and redeem gift cards in multiple currencies
- Subscription & membership gifting → recipients become subscribers automatically!
Insertr: Marketing Automation
We track Physical Marketing Performance like you're used to tracking Email Marketing Performance!
Key Features
- Add inserts as $0 line items, 3PLs pick & pack automatically
- Target by order value, customer tags, product type, and more
- Automatically apply FREE discount to inserted products.
- Works with any 3PL or WMS, no integration needed!
- Track ROI: measure subscription upsells & cross-sell conversions
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts5/5 Insertr: Marketing Automation5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 32 | 4 |
Reviews Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts32 Insertr: Marketing Automation4 | ||
| Core Function | Gift Card & Gifting Solutions | Physical Marketing Automation (Inserts) |
Core Function Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsGift Card & Gifting Solutions Insertr: Marketing AutomationPhysical Marketing Automation (Inserts) | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Multi-Currency Gift Cards | Automated Insert Application |
Key Feature 1 Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsMulti-Currency Gift Cards Insertr: Marketing AutomationAutomated Insert Application | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Product & Subscription Gifting | ROI Tracking for Inserts |
Key Feature 2 Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsProduct & Subscription Gifting Insertr: Marketing AutomationROI Tracking for Inserts | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses seeking to expand gifting options and gift card sales | Businesses looking to improve physical marketing performance and drive conversions |
Target Merchant Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsBusinesses seeking to expand gifting options and gift card sales Insertr: Marketing AutomationBusinesses looking to improve physical marketing performance and drive conversions | ||
| Ease of Use | Likely higher setup due to diverse features | Likely simple 3PL integration via $0 line items |
Ease of Use Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsLikely higher setup due to diverse features Insertr: Marketing AutomationLikely simple 3PL integration via $0 line items | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased revenue through gift card and gifting options; Enhanced customer experience | Improved marketing ROI through targeted inserts and conversion tracking |
Value Proposition Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsIncreased revenue through gift card and gifting options; Enhanced customer experience Insertr: Marketing AutomationImproved marketing ROI through targeted inserts and conversion tracking | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants looking to expand their gifting options and capitalize on gift card sales, Givy is the clear choice. Its comprehensive feature set addresses various gifting needs, from product gifting to corporate solutions. However, merchants seeking to optimize their physical marketing efforts and track the ROI of physical inserts should opt for Insertr. Insertr simplifies the process of including targeted marketing materials in orders, providing valuable insights into conversion rates and customer behavior. The choice depends entirely on the merchant's strategic goals: revenue growth through gifting (Givy) or enhanced marketing through inserts (Insertr).
Common Questions
Which app is better for increasing revenue?
Givy is designed to directly increase revenue through gift card sales and enabling product/subscription gifting. Insertr's impact on revenue is more indirect, achieved through upsells and cross-sells driven by targeted physical marketing.
Which app is easier to integrate with existing systems?
Insertr is likely easier to integrate because it requires no complex integrations; it adds inserts as $0 line items for your 3PL or WMS to handle seamlessly. Givy might require more setup to integrate with your existing CRM and marketing systems to fully leverage its gifting and loyalty features.
Which app is more focused on customer loyalty?
Both apps can contribute to customer loyalty. Givy can foster loyalty through easy gifting and personalized gift cards. Insertr builds loyalty through personalized inserts like thank-you cards and free samples, enhancing the post-purchase experience.
Which app is better for businesses with a strong focus on subscription services?
Givy offers a specific feature for subscription gifting, making it the better choice for businesses looking to expand their subscriber base through gifting.
If I already have a robust email marketing strategy, which app adds the most value?
Insertr would likely add more value if you already have a strong email marketing strategy. It allows you to complement your digital marketing efforts with tangible, personalized marketing materials in the physical realm, which can be particularly impactful.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store