Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts vs Monster Cart Upsell+Free Giftsfor Shopify (2026)
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts and Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts cater to different, though somewhat overlapping, needs within the Shopify ecosystem. Givy is primarily focused on expanding gift card functionality and enabling various gifting scenarios, including product gifting, subscription gifting, bulk gift card generation, and corporate gifting. Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts, on the other hand, concentrates on maximizing average order value through in-cart upsells, free gift promotions, and customizable cart functionalities. Therefore, Givy aims to enhance the gifting experience and generate revenue through gift card sales, while Monster Cart focuses on optimizing the existing customer's cart experience to increase spending.
At a Glance
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts
32 reviews
Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts
474 reviews
Detailed Overview
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts
Multi currency gift cards, product & subscription gifting, wrapping, corporate gifts, bulk vouchers
Key Features
- Product gifting → enable gifting on any product, send gift card as a gift
- Custom gift card amounts → sell gift cards with fixed or custom denominations
- Bulk gift cards & campaigns → email or print gift cards for loyal customers
- Multi-currency gift cards → buy and redeem gift cards in multiple currencies
- Subscription & membership gifting → recipients become subscribers automatically!
Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts
Unlock A Suite of Powerful Offers + In-Cart Upsells + Free Gift Rewards
Key Features
- Customize Your Slide Cart Drawer To Match Your Brand Perfectly.
- Add To Unlock Progress Bar + Free Gift, Discounts & Promotions and Free Shipping
- One Tick Upsell Offers for Shipping Protection, Priority Processing, Warranties
- BOGO + Buy More Save More product tiered discounts for boosting Upcart Revenue
- Frequently Bought Together with Shopify Machine learning or manual selection
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.7/5 |
Rating Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts5/5 Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts4.7/5 | ||
| Reviews | 32 | 474 |
Reviews Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts32 Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts474 | ||
| Primary Function | Gift card and gifting expansion | In-cart upsells and free gift promotions |
Primary Function Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsGift card and gifting expansion Monster Cart Upsell+Free GiftsIn-cart upsells and free gift promotions | ||
| Key Feature Differentiation | Multi-currency gift cards & Subscription gifting | Add to Unlock progress bar & One-click Upsell Offers |
Key Feature Differentiation Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsMulti-currency gift cards & Subscription gifting Monster Cart Upsell+Free GiftsAdd to Unlock progress bar & One-click Upsell Offers | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants wanting extensive gift card features and corporate gifting options. | Merchants focused on AOV optimization and cart customization. |
Target Merchant Type Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsMerchants wanting extensive gift card features and corporate gifting options. Monster Cart Upsell+Free GiftsMerchants focused on AOV optimization and cart customization. | ||
| Ease of Use (Inferred) | Potentially steeper learning curve due to feature richness. | Potentially easier implementation focused on cart functionality. |
Ease of Use (Inferred) Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsPotentially steeper learning curve due to feature richness. Monster Cart Upsell+Free GiftsPotentially easier implementation focused on cart functionality. | ||
| Value Proposition | Expand revenue streams through innovative gifting solutions. | Increase AOV and customer engagement through cart optimization. |
Value Proposition Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsExpand revenue streams through innovative gifting solutions. Monster Cart Upsell+Free GiftsIncrease AOV and customer engagement through cart optimization. | ||
| Multi-Currency Support | Supported for gift cards | Not Mentioned |
Multi-Currency Support Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsSupported for gift cards Monster Cart Upsell+Free GiftsNot Mentioned | ||
| Subscription Gifting | Supported | Not Supported |
Subscription Gifting Givy → Gift Cards & GiftsSupported Monster Cart Upsell+Free GiftsNot Supported | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
If a merchant's primary goal is to enhance their gift card offerings, enable diverse gifting options, and cater to corporate clients, Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts is the superior choice. Its multi-currency support, subscription gifting, and bulk gift card functionalities make it a comprehensive solution for gifting-focused businesses. Conversely, if the focus is strictly on increasing average order value through in-cart promotions, upsells, and cart customization features like progress bars and one-click upsells, then Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts is the better fit. The higher number of reviews for Monster Cart suggests a wider adoption and potentially greater ease of implementation for its core function.
Common Questions
Which app is better for merchants with international customers?
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts is better for merchants with international customers due to its multi-currency gift card support. Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts does not mention multi-currency support.
Can both apps be used simultaneously?
Potentially, but it might create a cluttered or confusing customer experience. Since they address different phases of the customer journey (gifting vs. cart optimization), careful integration and configuration would be necessary to avoid conflicts.
Which app is easier to set up and use?
Based on the description and features, Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts is likely easier to set up and use. Givy's wide range of gift card and gifting options might require more configuration and management.
Does either app support physical gift cards?
Givy → Gift Cards & Gifts supports linking digital gift cards to physical ones and printing in bulk. Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts does not mention support for physical gift cards.
Which app is better for increasing customer loyalty?
Both apps can contribute to customer loyalty. Givy does it through customized gift card campaigns and corporate gifting. Monster Cart does it via providing free gifts, tier discounts, and a better in-cart experience.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store