Happy Birthday Emails by UW vs PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testingfor Shopify (2026)
Happy Birthday Emails by UW and PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testing, while both listed under the 'Analytics' category on Shopify, cater to fundamentally different merchant needs and approaches. Happy Birthday Emails focuses on leveraging customer birthdays for personalized marketing and loyalty building through automated email campaigns and discount offers. Its strength lies in its simplicity and direct impact on customer retention and driving repeat purchases. The app explicitly states the ability to populate Shopify's customer birthday metafield, increasing the overall value of the collected information. PlusSales, on the other hand, is an AI-powered conversion rate optimization (CRO) tool designed to assist merchants in data-driven experimentation and website improvement. Its value comes from identifying areas for improvement on key store pages using a structured, hypothesis-driven approach based on real store metrics.
At a Glance
Happy Birthday Emails by UW
141 reviews
PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testing
6 reviews
Detailed Overview
Happy Birthday Emails by UW
Send a birthday email with a discount to build loyalty and repeat purchases
Key Features
- Send birthday emails with personalised messages and discounts
- Run a birthday loyalty campaign with zero ongoing effort
- Collect birthdays and age data at checkout, POS, or landing pages
- Works with your email platform or sends happy birthday emails for you
- Populates Shopify’s customer birthday metafield
PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testing
AI-powered CRO research that turns your analytics into test-ready hypotheses.
Key Features
- Analyzes your store across homepage, product pages, cart, and checkout.
- Connects to your analytics to pull funnel drop-offs, page performance
- Outputs structured hypotheses using IF-THEN-BECAUSE format with expected impact,
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Happy Birthday Emails by UW5/5 PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testing5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 141 | 6 |
Reviews Happy Birthday Emails by UW141 PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testing6 | ||
| Primary Function | Birthday Email Marketing & Loyalty | AI-Powered CRO Research & Hypothesis Generation |
Primary Function Happy Birthday Emails by UWBirthday Email Marketing & Loyalty PlusSales ‑ AI A/B TestingAI-Powered CRO Research & Hypothesis Generation | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants wanting to improve customer retention and drive repeat sales through personalized birthday offers | Merchants focused on conversion rate optimization (CRO) and data-driven website improvement. |
Target Merchant Happy Birthday Emails by UWMerchants wanting to improve customer retention and drive repeat sales through personalized birthday offers PlusSales ‑ AI A/B TestingMerchants focused on conversion rate optimization (CRO) and data-driven website improvement. | ||
| Analytics Focus | Customer age and purchase anniversaries. | Funnel drop-offs, page performance, UX issues |
Analytics Focus Happy Birthday Emails by UWCustomer age and purchase anniversaries. PlusSales ‑ AI A/B TestingFunnel drop-offs, page performance, UX issues | ||
| Ease of Use | Likely easier to set up; emphasizes automated birthday email sending | Requires more technical understanding and effort to implement A/B tests |
Ease of Use Happy Birthday Emails by UWLikely easier to set up; emphasizes automated birthday email sending PlusSales ‑ AI A/B TestingRequires more technical understanding and effort to implement A/B tests | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased customer loyalty and repeat purchases through personalized birthday greetings and offers. | Data-driven insights to improve conversion rates and maximize revenue. |
Value Proposition Happy Birthday Emails by UWIncreased customer loyalty and repeat purchases through personalized birthday greetings and offers. PlusSales ‑ AI A/B TestingData-driven insights to improve conversion rates and maximize revenue. | ||
| Data Collection Methods | Checkout, POS, or Landing Pages | Connects to GA4 and uses screenshots. |
Data Collection Methods Happy Birthday Emails by UWCheckout, POS, or Landing Pages PlusSales ‑ AI A/B TestingConnects to GA4 and uses screenshots. | ||
Our Verdict
Happy Birthday Emails by UW is ideal for merchants looking for a straightforward, automated solution to improve customer loyalty and drive repeat purchases through personalized birthday greetings and discount offers. Its simplicity and focus on automated marketing make it particularly suitable for smaller businesses or those with limited marketing resources. PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testing, is more suitable for larger or more established e-commerce businesses with dedicated marketing or CRO teams seeking data-driven insights to improve their website's conversion rates. While both are rated highly, the low review count of PlusSales should be noted - more reviews would add confidence in its long-term value. The choice depends entirely on whether the priority is customer retention through personalized marketing or data-driven conversion rate optimization.
Common Questions
Are both apps easy to set up and use?
Happy Birthday Emails is likely easier to set up as it focuses on automated email sending. PlusSales, requiring integration with GA4 and implementation of A/B tests, likely has a steeper learning curve.
Which app requires more technical expertise?
PlusSales ‑ AI A/B Testing requires more technical expertise as it involves connecting to Google Analytics 4, understanding A/B testing methodologies, and implementing code changes or using platforms like VWO or Optimizely.
Do both apps collect customer data?
Yes, Happy Birthday Emails collects customer birthday and age data. PlusSales connects to Google Analytics 4 to collect data about user behavior on the site.
Can these apps be used together?
Potentially, but indirectly. Happy Birthday Emails focuses on birthday-based marketing while PlusSales focuses on overall site optimization. The data from PlusSales could indirectly inform birthday offers by identifying top-selling products, for instance. However, there is no direct integration between them.
Which app provides a faster ROI?
It depends on the merchant's current situation. Happy Birthday Emails might show quicker results in terms of repeat purchases, while PlusSales's ROI depends on the effectiveness of the A/B tests and the time it takes to implement changes and see conversion improvements.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store