Product Picked vs RT: Smooth Scroll To Topfor Shopify (2026)
Product Picked and RT: Smooth Scroll To Top address fundamentally different aspects of the Shopify user experience, despite both falling under the broad 'Search and Navigation' category. Product Picked aims to improve product discovery and comprehension by leveraging AI to guide shoppers through personalized recommendations and product education. It positions itself as a digital in-store expert, ideal for stores with complex product catalogs or niches requiring customer education. In contrast, RT: Smooth Scroll To Top focuses on enhancing website usability by providing a quick and easy way for users to return to the top of long pages. It caters to stores with extensive content, improving navigation convenience for shoppers, and mitigating the need for this functionality within a store's native theme. The apps target different stages of the sales funnel: Product Picked assists pre-purchase, while Smooth Scroll To Top is focused on general page navigation. RT: Smooth Scroll To Top enjoys a strong reputation with a perfect 5/5 rating based on 30 reviews, suggesting high user satisfaction. Its value proposition centers on simplicity and immediate usability; adding a crucial navigation feature with minimal effort. Product Picked, however, currently lacks any reviews, presenting a risk for merchants considering the app. Its unproven AI-powered recommendation engine introduces potential complexities in setup and maintenance compared to the straightforward functionality of RT: Smooth Scroll To Top. The key difference lies in the sophistication and potential impact of each app on the customer journey. One provides streamlined navigation while the other provides advanced pre-sale recommendations.
At a Glance
Product Picked
0 reviews
RT: Smooth Scroll To Top
30 reviews
Detailed Overview
Product Picked
Help shoppers make smart purchases with AI-powered guidance, product education, and recommendation.
Key Features
- Educates shoppers on your products, just like an in-store expert would.
- Our smart quiz asks the right questions and gives a tailored recommendation.
- Integrates with your existing product catalog.
- Easy setup - our theme extension block supports any theme.
RT: Smooth Scroll To Top
A button allows the user to quickly return to the top of the page without making too much effort.
Key Features
- Add a Scroll To Top button to your store in just one click!
- Help visitors navigate your store with a scroll progress bar
- Fully customize the button's color, shape, size, position, and much more
- The button is shown only when scrolling up and down is possible
- Allow customers to easily browse long pages and increase sales and conversions!
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Product Picked0/5 RT: Smooth Scroll To Top5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 30 |
Reviews Product Picked0 RT: Smooth Scroll To Top30 | ||
| Primary Function | AI-powered product recommendations & education | Scroll to top button for improved navigation |
Primary Function Product PickedAI-powered product recommendations & education RT: Smooth Scroll To TopScroll to top button for improved navigation | ||
| Target Merchant | Stores with complex product catalogs, needing to educate customers | Stores with long pages and content-heavy designs |
Target Merchant Product PickedStores with complex product catalogs, needing to educate customers RT: Smooth Scroll To TopStores with long pages and content-heavy designs | ||
| Ease of Use | Theme extension block with potentially complex AI setup | One-click installation, customizable button |
Ease of Use Product PickedTheme extension block with potentially complex AI setup RT: Smooth Scroll To TopOne-click installation, customizable button | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased conversions through personalized recommendations and product understanding | Improved user experience and navigation convenience on long pages |
Value Proposition Product PickedIncreased conversions through personalized recommendations and product understanding RT: Smooth Scroll To TopImproved user experience and navigation convenience on long pages | ||
| Risk | No reviews, unproven AI performance | Low risk, simple functionality |
Risk Product PickedNo reviews, unproven AI performance RT: Smooth Scroll To TopLow risk, simple functionality | ||
| Customization | Integrates with existing product catalog | Fully customizable button appearance |
Customization Product PickedIntegrates with existing product catalog RT: Smooth Scroll To TopFully customizable button appearance | ||
Our Verdict
RT: Smooth Scroll To Top is the clear choice for merchants seeking an immediate and reliable solution to improve website navigation, particularly on content-rich pages. Its high rating and positive reviews demonstrate its effectiveness and ease of use. Given the absence of reviews and the inherent complexity of AI-powered recommendations, Product Picked presents a greater risk.
Product Picked may hold promise for merchants with complex or niche product offerings requiring personalized guidance, but its lack of validation makes it difficult to recommend without further evidence of its effectiveness. Merchants should carefully weigh the potential benefits of AI-driven recommendations against the uncertainty and potentially higher setup/maintenance costs compared to the established reliability of RT: Smooth Scroll To Top. If you are a store owner looking for a tested and reliable navigation feature, RT: Smooth Scroll To Top is the safer choice.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
RT: Smooth Scroll To Top is significantly easier to set up with its one-click installation and customizable button. Product Picked involves theme integration and configuration of the AI-powered recommendation engine, which may require more technical expertise.
Which app is better for improving conversions?
Product Picked *potentially* has a higher ceiling for improving conversions through personalized product recommendations. However, RT: Smooth Scroll To Top can indirectly improve conversions by enhancing user experience and making it easier for customers to browse products and complete purchases.
Are both apps compatible with all Shopify themes?
RT: Smooth Scroll To Top should be compatible with nearly all themes, given its straightforward functionality. Product Picked claims theme extension block support, but compatibility may vary and require testing with specific themes.
Which app requires more ongoing maintenance?
Product Picked likely requires more ongoing maintenance due to the AI component and the need to ensure recommendations remain relevant and accurate. RT: Smooth Scroll To Top requires minimal to no maintenance after initial setup.
If my theme already has a scroll-to-top button, do I need RT: Smooth Scroll To Top?
No. If your theme already has a scroll-to-top button that functions well, RT: Smooth Scroll To Top would be redundant. It is designed for themes lacking this feature.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store