Scrolly: Scroll To Top Button vs Shopify Search & Discoveryfor Shopify (2026)
Scrolly: Scroll To Top Button and Shopify Search & Discovery, while both falling under the broader category of 'Search and navigation' on Shopify, address fundamentally different aspects of the user experience. Scrolly focuses on a single, highly specific UI enhancement: adding a customizable 'scroll to top' button to improve site navigation. Its strength lies in its simplicity, ease of use (one-click installation, no code required), and the ability to quickly customize the button's appearance to match the store's brand. The target audience is merchants seeking a quick and simple way to improve website usability and potentially increase conversions by making it easier for customers to navigate lengthy pages. Shopify Search & Discovery, on the other hand, is a much more comprehensive app that aims to improve the overall search and product discovery experience. It offers a suite of features including customizable filters, synonym groups for improved search accuracy, product boosting, and product recommendations. This app targets merchants who want to actively optimize their product presentation, improve search relevance, and increase average order value. While it has a lower rating than Scrolly, it boasts a significantly larger number of reviews, which could indicate broader adoption and a more comprehensive feature set. The primary difference is that Scrolly focuses on a single, visual UI element, while Search & Discovery is a more strategic tool focused on backend optimization of search functionality and product presentation.
At a Glance
Scrolly: Scroll To Top Button
109 reviews
Shopify Search & Discovery
485 reviews
Detailed Overview
Scrolly: Scroll To Top Button
Add a stylish scroll to top button to your store that matches your style. One click installation.
Key Features
- Ease your customers shopping experience with a colorful back to top button.
- Fully matches your store's style: Custom color, shape, size, animation & more.
- Control the appearance location: In the entire store or just in specific pages.
- Multiple shapes and styles are available, unlimited color and size options.
- Easy one click installation & universal theme support - no code is required.
Shopify Search & Discovery
Help customers find the right products and sell more using Shopify’s free Search & Discovery app
Key Features
- Customize filters to let shoppers refine their search by multiple categories.
- Make synonym groups, so product descriptions match the terms shoppers use.
- Use product boosts to feature products you want highlighted in search results.
- Add related and complementary products on product detail pages.
- Access analytics to understand your store’s search and discovery performance.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4/5 |
Rating Scrolly: Scroll To Top Button4.9/5 Shopify Search & Discovery4/5 | ||
| Reviews | 109 | 485 |
Reviews Scrolly: Scroll To Top Button109 Shopify Search & Discovery485 | ||
| Primary Focus | Scroll to Top Button | Search & Product Discovery Optimization |
Primary Focus Scrolly: Scroll To Top ButtonScroll to Top Button Shopify Search & DiscoverySearch & Product Discovery Optimization | ||
| Key Feature: Customization | Button appearance (color, shape, size, animation) | Filters, synonyms, product boosts, recommendations |
Key Feature: Customization Scrolly: Scroll To Top ButtonButton appearance (color, shape, size, animation) Shopify Search & DiscoveryFilters, synonyms, product boosts, recommendations | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants wanting a simple UI improvement | Merchants wanting to optimize search, discovery, and AOV |
Target Merchant Type Scrolly: Scroll To Top ButtonMerchants wanting a simple UI improvement Shopify Search & DiscoveryMerchants wanting to optimize search, discovery, and AOV | ||
| Ease of Use | One-click installation, no code required | Requires configuration and strategy |
Ease of Use Scrolly: Scroll To Top ButtonOne-click installation, no code required Shopify Search & DiscoveryRequires configuration and strategy | ||
| Value Proposition | Improved website usability & potentially higher conversion rate | Increased product visibility, better search results, higher AOV, and data-driven insights. |
Value Proposition Scrolly: Scroll To Top ButtonImproved website usability & potentially higher conversion rate Shopify Search & DiscoveryIncreased product visibility, better search results, higher AOV, and data-driven insights. | ||
Our Verdict
The choice between Scrolly: Scroll To Top Button and Shopify Search & Discovery depends heavily on the merchant's needs and resources. For merchants who are primarily concerned with improving the basic usability of their website with a quick and easy fix, Scrolly is the clear choice. Its simple installation and customization options make it accessible to all levels of technical expertise.
However, merchants who are serious about optimizing their search and discovery experience to maximize sales should invest in Shopify Search & Discovery. While it may require more effort to set up and configure, the potential returns from improved search relevance, increased product visibility, and higher average order values are likely to be significant. Shopify Search & Discovery is the better option for merchants willing to invest time and effort into optimizing their product presentation and search functionality, while Scrolly is perfect for a quick and easy usability enhancement.
Common Questions
Does Scrolly offer analytics to track button usage?
The provided description for Scrolly does not mention any analytics features. It primarily focuses on customization and ease of use.
Can Shopify Search & Discovery customize the appearance of the search bar itself?
The description focuses on customizing filters, synonyms, and product recommendations, not the appearance of the search bar directly. Further research within the app would be necessary to confirm the extent of search bar customization.
Is Scrolly compatible with all Shopify themes?
The description claims 'universal theme support,' suggesting broad compatibility, but testing with specific themes is always recommended.
Does Shopify Search & Discovery offer A/B testing capabilities for product recommendations?
The provided description does not specifically mention A/B testing. It focuses on customization and analytics, but A/B testing might be a feature within the analytics suite, which would require further investigation.
If I install both apps, will they conflict with each other?
It's unlikely they will conflict, as Scrolly affects a specific UI element (the scroll to top button) while Shopify Search & Discovery focuses on search functionality and product discovery. They address different aspects of the shopping experience.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store