Collectify: Get More Emails vs Win‑Win Store Creditfor Shopify (2026)
Collectify: Get More Emails and Win‑Win Store Credit, while both aiming to boost revenue, take vastly different approaches. Collectify focuses on the top of the funnel by maximizing email list growth through embedded forms on product pages and offering instant discounts for email sign-ups. It's tailored for merchants prioritizing list building and email marketing strategies. In contrast, Win‑Win Store Credit concentrates on customer retention by incentivizing repeat purchases through post-purchase store credit. It highlights prominent store credit displays and bulk issuance options. The primary distinction lies in their core function: lead generation (Collectify) versus customer loyalty (Win‑Win). Collectify integrates seamlessly with existing email marketing workflows (like Klaviyo pop-ups) to enhance email capture rates, targeting first-time visitors browsing product pages. Win-Win Store Credit, on the other hand, focuses on turning existing customers into repeat buyers by making store credit visible and easy to claim. It targets merchants struggling with repeat purchase rates and customer lifetime value. Ultimately, the choice hinges on the merchant's current needs and marketing priorities. Merchants heavily invested in email marketing and seeking to expand their subscriber base might favor Collectify. Those looking to improve customer retention and encourage repeat business are better suited for Win‑Win Store Credit.
At a Glance
Collectify: Get More Emails
1 reviews
Win‑Win Store Credit
3 reviews
Detailed Overview
Collectify: Get More Emails
Collectify helps you collect more emails --> So you can send more emails --> To generate more money!
Key Features
- Create custom, embedded email collection forms on product pages.
- Capture customers email & interest for enhanced segmentation & marketing.
- Issue instant discounts to visitors sessions that provide their email address.
- Forms only shown to first time potential customers.
- Stacks and works with your home page pop ups to maximize emails collected.
Win‑Win Store Credit
Offer post-purchase store credit and watch the repeat orders come in! Prominent display & CSV upload
Key Features
- Post-Purchase: Let your customers claim store credit for a future purchase.
- Bulk Issue: Use customer filters or CSV upload to issue store credit in bulk.
- Display: Prominently show store credit in header bar or floating in corner.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Collectify: Get More Emails5/5 Win‑Win Store Credit5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1 | 3 |
Reviews Collectify: Get More Emails1 Win‑Win Store Credit3 | ||
| Core Function | Email List Growth | Customer Retention |
Core Function Collectify: Get More EmailsEmail List Growth Win‑Win Store CreditCustomer Retention | ||
| Target Audience | Merchants prioritizing email marketing | Merchants prioritizing repeat purchases |
Target Audience Collectify: Get More EmailsMerchants prioritizing email marketing Win‑Win Store CreditMerchants prioritizing repeat purchases | ||
| Key Feature | Embedded email forms on product pages | Post-purchase store credit display |
Key Feature Collectify: Get More EmailsEmbedded email forms on product pages Win‑Win Store CreditPost-purchase store credit display | ||
| Primary Benefit | Increased email subscribers | Improved customer loyalty and repeat orders |
Primary Benefit Collectify: Get More EmailsIncreased email subscribers Win‑Win Store CreditImproved customer loyalty and repeat orders | ||
| Ease of Use (based on description) | Install in 10 minutes | Prominent display & CSV upload |
Ease of Use (based on description) Collectify: Get More EmailsInstall in 10 minutes Win‑Win Store CreditProminent display & CSV upload | ||
| Value Proposition | Generate more revenue through email marketing | Drive repeat orders with store credit |
Value Proposition Collectify: Get More EmailsGenerate more revenue through email marketing Win‑Win Store CreditDrive repeat orders with store credit | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing lead generation and building a strong email list, Collectify: Get More Emails is the better choice. Its focus on capturing emails from product page visitors with incentives like discounts directly addresses the need for list growth. It's particularly useful if you're already using email marketing platforms like Klaviyo and want to augment your existing efforts.
Conversely, if your primary goal is to improve customer retention and encourage repeat purchases, Win‑Win Store Credit is the superior option. The emphasis on visible store credit and easy redemption creates a powerful incentive for customers to return and spend their earned credit. This is especially effective for businesses with a high churn rate or a need to boost customer lifetime value.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Collectify claims to be installable in 10 minutes, suggesting a potentially simpler setup process. Win-Win Store Credit involves configuring store credit displays and potentially using CSV uploads for bulk issuance, which might require more initial configuration.
Which app is better for a new Shopify store?
Both apps can be beneficial, but Collectify might be slightly more advantageous for a brand new store. Building an email list early on is crucial, and Collectify helps accelerate that process. Win-Win Store Credit is more effective once you have established a customer base to incentivize repeat purchases.
Can these apps be used together?
Yes, they can. Collectify focuses on attracting new leads, while Win-Win Store Credit rewards existing customers. A combined approach can create a comprehensive strategy for both acquisition and retention.
Which app offers better long-term value?
It depends on your business model. A large, engaged email list built with Collectify can provide ongoing value through targeted marketing campaigns. Increased customer loyalty fostered by Win-Win Store Credit translates into repeat revenue and higher customer lifetime value, also offering long-term benefits.
How does Collectify integrate with my existing email marketing?
Collectify's description states that it 'stacks and works with your homepage pop ups to maximize emails collected,' implying compatibility with existing email marketing workflows, presumably by adding another touchpoint for email collection on product pages.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store