Best Alternatives to Toki Loyalty Program & Rewardsfor Shopify (2026)

While not a direct replacement for a loyalty program, Shopney offers an entirely different approach to customer retention through a dedicated mobile app. Merchants may choose Shopney to provide a superior mobile shopping experience and use push notifications to achieve the same retention goals as a loyalty program through targeted promotions.

If your focus is on building recurring revenue through subscriptions, Recurpay is a great fit. Although Toki might offer some membership options, Recurpay specializes in subscription management, customer portals, and recurring payments, providing a more feature-rich environment for subscription-based businesses.

If your primary goal is referral marketing and affiliate programs, Affiliate Marketing ReferrLy offers a robust solution. Unlike Toki, which includes referrals as part of a broader loyalty suite, ReferrLy specializes in affiliate onboarding, commission rules, and performance tracking, offering more focused features in this area.

GoodAPI provides a completely different avenue to customer loyalty by focusing on sustainability. If your target audience is environmentally conscious, GoodAPI allows you to build loyalty through tree planting and ocean plastic removal initiatives, directly aligning your brand with their values.

While not a direct loyalty program, Swish (Wishlist King) enhances customer engagement by allowing them to save desired products. Merchants might choose this if they find wishlists to be a strong driver of sales and want a more specialized wishlist solution with advanced analytics and integrations.

Froonze combines loyalty and wishlist functionality within a single customer account interface. If you desire both features and want a unified experience, Froonze might be a convenient alternative, especially with its integration with Shopify's native store credit.

Wishify offers a streamlined wishlist solution that prioritizes sharing and driving traffic. If your focus is purely on enhancing the wishlist experience and leveraging it for social sharing and reminders, Wishify provides a focused set of features.

E! Loyalty Program & Rewards provides a similar all-in-one loyalty program experience to Toki, including points, referrals, and VIP tiers. It may be a viable alternative if you're seeking a different user interface, pricing structure, or a particular feature that E! offers that Toki does not.

BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty offers a similar comprehensive loyalty program with points, rewards, VIP tiers, and referral options. It distinguishes itself by highlighting retention-led customer acquisition and a focus on rewards customers actually redeem, emphasizing effective loyalty program design.

Love Loyalty Program & Rewards focuses on a fast and seamless customer experience, particularly with cart redemption and numerous storefront placements. If speed and placement options are a priority, this might be a better fit than Toki.